Hospital episode statistics: improving the quality and value of hospital data: a national internet e-survey of hospital consultants

Abstract

HypothesisSenior hospital clinicians are poorly engaged with clinical coding and hospital episode statistics (HES).Aims ▸ To understand the current level of clinical engagement with collection of national data and clinical coding.▸ To gain the views of frontline staff on proposed improvements to hospital statistics.▸ To gain an indication of likely clinical engagement in change.▸ To understand the clinical priority for improvement.DesignInternet e-survey accessible from Academy of Royal Medical College Website.SettingNational Health Service (NHS) Trusts.Participants1081 NHS hospital consultants and two general practitioners who volunteered to take part.Results3.4% of the sample regularly access HES data; 21% are regularly involved in clinical coding and 6.2% meet coding staff at least monthly. 95% would like to access HES data and there was a strong support for using this data for appraisal, revalidation and improving the quality of patient care. In terms of improvements, 91.9% would be prepared to code diagnosis in outpatients given the right tools. The highest priority for improvement is clinical validation of diagnostic data.ConclusionsClinical engagement with coding and access to HES data is poor. However, there is professional support for improvement. Clinical requirements should be considered in all future developments of national data collection to provide the quality and scope of data that is required to deliver the information revolution.

Pulmonary embolism and mortality following total ankle replacement: a data linkage study using the NJR data set

“…A national audit of a large UK trust into clinical coding revealed that in orthopaedics 20% of diagnosis and 19% of procedures are coded inaccurately 25. Therefore, although we employed a robust method to identify ankle replacement more accurately, the actual identification of PE was still limited by accuracy of clinical coding.…”

Patients with diabetes requiring emergency department care for hypoglycaemia: characteristics and long-term outcomes determined from multiple data sources

“…Coded data are a poor reflection of clinical practice, though this has improved in the last decade 19 20. In this study, only 34 out of 108 (31%) eligible episodes identified from AERs were recorded using the code for diabetes-related emergency calls.…”

“…HES is a database that contains details of all ED attendances, hospital admissions and outpatient appointments at all NHS hospitals across the whole of England 19. The main purpose of HES data is to allow hospitals to be paid for the care they deliver.…”

National neonatal data to support specialist care and improve infant outcomes

“…While HES is derived directly from hospital's own data submissions for PbR, the quality and utility of these data have been subject to the reports of substantial missing data, inconsistent coding and poor data definitions 22 23. The Academy of Royal Medical Colleges has recently called for a number of improvements so that clinicians become more engaged with the collection of national data 24. In neonatal medicine, the availability of high-quality data captured at the point of care by clinical teams has led clinicians to ignore HES neonatal data.…”