Hot and Cool Executive Function in Elite- and Amateur- Adolescent Athletes From Open and Closed Skills Sports

Abstract

Background: Executive functions (EFs) not only play an important role in shaping adolescent's goal-directed, future-oriented cognitive skills under relatively abstract, non-affective conditions (Cool EF), but also under motivationally significant, affective conditions (Hot EF). Empirical evidence suggest a link between EF, exercise and physical activity, specifically elite adult athletes appear to outperform amateur athletes in Cool EF; however, no previous studies have examined the relationship between Hot and Cool EFs and impulsivity during the developmentally sensitive period of adolescence comparing different types of sport (open-vs. closed-skills), and levels (elite athletes vs. amateurs). Methods: A total 86 boys and girls between 13 and 15 years of age (mean: 14.0, SD: 0.79) from different sports (track-and-field; team handball) were recruited. Participants were further divided into two groups: (a) 40 elite, and (b) 46 amateur athletes. They completed four Cool EF tasks including Trail-Making Test, Trail-Walking-Test, Flanker task, n-back-task, and one Hot EF task on Game of Dice task. Data on subjective impulsivity (UPPS Impulsive Behavior Scale; Barratt Impulsiveness Scale-15) was also collected. Results: There was a significant overall effect for expertise in favor of elite athletes (Wilks' Lambda = 0.61, F(14,69) = 3.19, p = 0.001,η 2 p = 0.393), but no overall main effect for type of sport or an interaction for expertise by type of sport. Specifically, elite athletes showed significantly better performances on dual tasks. For Hot EF, there were no main effects for type of sport, expertise level, training experience or training duration. We also found positive correlations among Cool EF and impulsivity measures, and between Hot EF and Impulsivity, but no significant relationship between Cool and Hot EF. Conclusion: The current understanding of the decisive cognitive abilities does not correspond to sporting reality, so that the tests frequently used are not sensitive enough to distinguish between elite and amateur athletes or different sports. However, it should also be remembered that the factors underlying complex sporting performance are multidimensional and are obviously difficult to trace back to selected partial

Decision making under ambiguity and risk in adolescent-onset schizophrenia

“…Meanwhile, there is a positive correlation between net/total score on IGT and score on the digital span backward but not the digital span forward in the present study, which may be most likely attributed to the asumption that digital span backward required more cognitive processing, especially depending on the executive resources [ 61 ]. These associations concurred with those shown in other previous studies [ 34 , 39 , 62 ]. However, different with previous researches during the DM processes, our present study showed an inconsistent performance that clinical symptoms were unrelated to DM processes.…”

Cognitive and Executive Functions of Young Men regarding Sport Activity and Personality Traits

“…This is probably the reason why there is no difference between open and closed skill sport athletes in several other studies. These findings are thus consistent with other research [42] focused on the cognitive and executive functions of track-and-field athletes and handball players. The authors found no difference between athletes in terms of sport disciplines.…”

The Effects of the Combination of High-Intensity Interval Training with 3D-Multiple Object Tracking Task on Perceptual-Cognitive Performance: A Randomized Controlled Intervention Trial

“…A questionnaire for sports biography was used to determine what type of sport the participants did and how often they exercised per week to participate in the intervention study. Since sport type determines differences in executive functions in elite athletes [ 33 , 34 ], the sports biography was categorized into static sports (self-paced activities in highly consistent circumstances, e.g., taekwondo, athletics, and dancing, etc. ), strategic sports (requiring the adaption to highly varying situations considering teammates, opponents, positions or objects, e.g., soccer, basketball, handball, and volleyball, etc.)…”