How Do General Practitioners Respond to Reports of Abnormal Chest X-rays?

Abstract

General practitioners (GPs) in the UK have long had direct access to hospital radiological services, which in theory shortens investigation time and improves the quality of service. Chest X-rays (CXRs) account for a substantial proportion of requests, and we investigated what happened when an abnormality was detected. In one year, 204 GPs in the Nottingham area requested CXRs in 605 patients. 362 were reported normal, 165 abnormal but hospital follow-up not indicated and 71 abnormal with radiological follow-up or hospital referral indicated (mass lesion suspicious of tumours 27, infective shadowing 35, other 9). 64 of the 71 were seen in hospital within three months, and in those with suspected cancer the median time to follow-up was 20 days. These results show that GPs do act on the results of abnormal CXRs, but only 37% of those with a mass suspicious of cancer were seen in hospital within two weeks as recommended by the British Thoracic Society. Time might be saved if GPs agreed to direct referral from the radiology department to respiratory physicians.

Direct access cancer testing in primary care: a systematic review of use and clinical outcomes

“…Gastroscopy was the most commonly studied DA test (27 studies), followed by lower GI endoscopy (proctoscopy, flexible sigmoidoscopy, or colonoscopy, 15 studies), [50][51][52][53][54][55][56][57][58][59][60][61][62][63][64] CT (three studies -two head, one chest), [65][66][67] ultrasound (three studiestwo abdominal, one gynaecological), [68][69][70] MRI (three studies), [71][72][73] X-ray (two studies), 74,75 gastroscopy and lower endoscopy combined (two studies), 76,77 mammogram (one study), 78 mammogram and ultrasound combined (one study), 79 MRI and CT combined (one study), 80,81 transvaginal sonography (one study), 82 and a range of radiological tests including MRI, CT, and barium meal (one study). 83 Fifty-seven studies (95%) reported DA testing performed in a hospital or specialist clinic setting, one utilised a DA test located in primary care, 28 and two did not specify location.…”

Timeliness of care in patients with lung cancer: a systematic review

“…Reported median times from the primary care visit to referral for specialist evaluation were 13 days (range 0–21 days),48 16 days,6 33 days (IQR 12–68 days)49 and 33 days (range 0–477 days) 39. Two studies demonstrated that patients often made multiple visits to their primary care physician before additional investigation were initiated 50 51.…”