(How) do medical students regulate their emotions?

Abstract

BackgroundMedical training can be a challenging and emotionally intense period for medical students. However the emotions experienced by medical students in the face of challenging situations and the emotion regulation strategies they use remains relatively unexplored. The aim of the present study was to explore the emotions elicited by memorable incidents reported by medical students and the associated emotion regulation strategies.MethodsPeer interviewing was used to collect medical students’ memorable incidents. Medical students at both preclinical and clinical stage of medical school were eligible to participate. In total 104 medical students provided memorable incidents. Only 54 narratives included references to emotions and emotion regulation and thus were further analyzed.ResultsThe narratives of 47 clinical and 7 preclinical students were further analyzed for their references to emotions and emotion regulation strategies. Forty seven out of 54 incidents described a negative incident associated with negative emotions. The most frequently mentioned emotion was shock and surprise followed by feelings of embarrassment, sadness, anger and tension or anxiety. The most frequent reaction was inaction often associated with emotion regulation strategies such as distraction, focusing on a task, suppression of emotions and reappraisal. When students witnessed mistreatment or disrespect exhibited towards patients, the regulation strategy used involved focusing and comforting the patient.ConclusionsThe present study sheds light on the strategies medical students use to deal with intense negative emotions. The vast majority reported inaction in the face of a challenging situation and the use of more subtle strategies to deal with the emotional impact of the incident.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12909-016-0832-9) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

‘Waiting in the wings’; Lived experience at the threshold of clinical practice

“…The hidden curriculum cultivates a tolerance of bad behaviour in the clinical setting . Although provoking feelings of despair and hopelessness among students, a common response is to remain impassive and expressionless . They may excuse the unprofessional behaviour of senior doctors, instead implicating external factors such as workload or fatigue, or they may blame themselves for it .…”

Distraction‐focused interventions on examination stress in nursing students: Effects on psychological stress and biomarker levels. A randomized controlled trial

“…Anxiety already occurs in the phase of anticipation, increases during the confrontation and then slowly decreases again. In performance situations, the successful regulation of emotions is crucial, and emotion-focused strategies, like distraction, can be useful then (Doulougeri, Panagopoulou, & Montgomery, 2016;McRae et al, 2010;Suls & Fletcher, 1985). Cognitive strategies mainly address the component 'anxiety', and they may fail in controlling fear responses in acute stress situations (Raio, Orederu, Palazzolo, Shurick, & Phelps, 2013).…”

Cognitive Reappraisal and Expressive Suppression of Negative Emotion in Combat-Related Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: A Functional MRI Study

“…Early strategies aim to modify an emotional response before it occurs, such as through reinterpreting the meaning or context of a stimulus-situation-focused cognitive reappraisal-or by modifying one's perspective-selffocused cognitive reappraisal (Ochsner et al 2004;Willroth and Hilimire 2016). For example, when faced with a challenging situation, a medical professional may adopt a professional distance to perceive it in a detached and objective manner rather than a personal or emotional one (Doulougeri et al 2016;Ochsner et al 2004;Shapiro 2013). In contrast, late strategies attempt to inhibit an emotional response once it has already occurred, for example, by suppressing any outward expression of emotion.…”