How Do People with Multiple Sclerosis Experience Prognostic Uncertainty and Prognosis Communication? A Qualitative Study

Abstract

BackgroundDisease progression in multiple sclerosis (MS) is highly variable and predicting prognosis is notoriously challenging. Patients’ prognosis beliefs, responses to prognostic uncertainty and experiences of prognosis-related communication with healthcare professionals (HCPs) have received little study. These issues have implications for patients’ psychological adjustment and are important in the context of the recent development of personalised prognosis forecasting tools. This study explored patient perspectives on the experience of prognostic uncertainty, the formation of expectations about personal prognosis and the nature of received and desired prognosis communication.Methods15 MS patients participated in in-depth semi-structured interviews which were analysed using inductive thematic analysis.ResultsSix themes captured key aspects of the data: Experiencing unsatisfactory communication with HCPs, Appreciating and accepting prognostic uncertainty, Trying to stay present-focused, Forming and editing personal prognosis beliefs, Ambivalence towards forecasting the future, and Prognosis information delivery. MS patients report having minimal communication with HCPs about prognosis. Over time MS patients appear to develop expectations about their disease trajectories, but do so with minimal HCP input. Provision of prognosis information by HCPs seems to run counter to patients’ attempts to remain present-focused. Patients are often ambivalent about prognosis forecasting and consider it emotionally dangerous and of circumscribed usefulness.ConclusionsHCPs must carefully consider whether, when and how to share prognosis information with patients; specific training may be beneficial. Future research should confirm findings about limited HCP-patient communication, distinguish predictors of patients’ attitudes towards prognostication and identify circumstances under which prognostic forecasting benefits patients.

“…Not Having the Real Support That We Need”: Patients’ Experiences With Ambiguity of Systemic Lupus Erythematosus and Erosion of Social Support

“…Our findings are consistent with studies aiming to elucidate patient experiences in other chronic rheumatic diseases such as systemic sclerosis (SSc) (12), rheumatoid arthritis (RA) (32, 33), and multiple sclerosis (MS) (34). Overlapping themes include dealing with uncertainty (SSc, RA, MS), poor communication with physicians (MS), inadequate physician validation (SSc), role changes (SSc, RA), and poor availability of disease information (SSc).…”

“It's Not Me, It's Not Really Me.” Insights From Patients on Living With Systemic Sclerosis: An Interview Study

“…Patients felt misunderstood because of the rarity of the disease and as a consequence experienced extreme social isolation. Furthermore, unlike other rheumatic diseases, SSc was perceived to be unpredictable and less certain, similar to patient's views of multiple sclerosis .…”

Fear, fight, familiarize: the experiences of people living with relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis and taking oral medication

“…This study followed a phenomenological design. Phenomenology is the study of "phenomena" or things as they appear in our experience (Smith, 2016). Phenomenological studies are concerned with exploring experience in its own terms.…”

“…Various qualitative studies have shown that the onset of MS is characterized by experiences of uncertainty, loss, and grief (Dennison, McCloy Smith, Bradbury, & Galea, 2016;Finlay, 2003;Soundy, Roskell, Elder, Collett, & Dawes, 2016;Toombs, 1995). The philosopher Toombs (1995, p. 12), who suffers from MS herself, describes living with MS as experiencing "a global disorder.…”