Principles of diversity lie at the heart of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and are reflected in education policies worldwide. However, the translation of these principles into culturally responsive pedagogy (CRP) is problematic. This paper reports on a study conducted in kindergarten rooms of four long day care centres in Australia investigating educator practice when sharing culturally diverse children’s literature. Twenty-four educators and 110 children participated. Data was collected through field notes, semi-structured interviews, and video recordings. Findings show in the majority of book sharing in these centres the cultures, backgrounds, life experiences and funds of knowledge of children from underrepresented backgrounds were invisible. Further, educators’ practices were bereft of CRP and likely to demean and confuse those from underrepresented backgrounds and increase all children’s misconceptions of those different to themselves.