How is family health history discussed in routine primary healthcare? A qualitative study of archived family doctor consultations

Abstract

ObjectivesFamily health history underpins genetic medicine. Our study aimed to explore language and patterns of communication relating to family health history observed in interactions between general practitioners (GPs) and their patients within routine primary care consultations.DesignSecondary analysis of patient and GP routine consultation data (n=252).ParticipantsConsultations that included ‘family health history’ were eligible for inclusion (n=58).Primary outcomesA qualitative inductive analysis of the interactions from consultation transcripts.Results46/58 conversations about family health history were initiated by the GP. Most discussions around family history lasted for between approximately 1 to 2 min. Patients were invited to share family health history through one of two ways: non-specific enquiry (eg, by asking the patient about ‘anything that runs in the family’); or specific enquiry where they were asked if they had a ‘strong family history’ in relation to a particular condition, for example, breast cancer. Patients often responded to either approach with a simple no, but fuller negative responses also occurred regularly and typically included an account of some kind (eg, explaining family relationships/dynamics which impeded or prevented the accessibility of information).ConclusionsFamily health history is regarded as a genetic test and is embedded in the sociocultural norms of the patient from whom information is being sought. Our findings highlight that it is more complex than asking simply if ‘anything’ runs in the family. As the collection of family health history is expected to be more routine, it will be important to also consider it from sociocultural perspectives in order to help mitigate any inequities in how family history is collected, and therefore used (or not) in a person’s healthcare. Orientating an enquiry away from ‘anything’ and asking more specific details about particular conditions may help facilitate the dialogue.

Coronary risk factor profiles according to different age categories in premature coronary artery disease patients who have undergone percutaneous coronary intervention

“…Moreover, a significant number of patients responded with an uncooperative answer or simply replied ‘no,’ which posed a challenge in obtaining a comprehensive and accurate family history. This was often attributed to the personal preference of patients where they preferred not to disclose such information 37 . On the other hand, a detailed family history of three generations of relatives, health issues with age of onset, the age and cause of death for each family member was estimated to lasts up to 30 min 38 .…”

Combining rare and common genetic variants improves population risk stratification for breast cancer

“…Guidelines suggest that women with a parent, sibling, or child diagnosed with breast cancer, or who have early onset breast cancer themselves, may benefit from earlier screening. Despite operational and practical challenges, the ascertainment of family history is recommended 26,27 . Challenges to ascertaining family history include time constraints during medical visits, smaller family sizes, families with adopted members, families that do not discuss health issues, and male-dominant pedigrees.…”