There is a need to assess the sustainability of current harvest levels of wild birds in the United Kingdom (UK), and more widely, across Europe. Yet data on population and harvest size, as well as population demographics of many species are limited.We used a Demographic Invariant Method (DIM) to estimate Potential Excess Growth (PEG) for populations of waterbirds wintering in the UK and calculated a Sustainable Harvest Index (SHI) for each species or population. We compared this with population trends and conservation classifications (e.g. Birds of Conservation Concern) to assess the sustainability of harvests and the utility of these classifications.Our approach found no evidence for overharvest of any duck or wader species, except potentially for gadwall Mareca strepera. We estimated that Canada geese Branta canadensis and both British and Icelandic greylag geese Anser anser are potentially overharvested in the UK. With the exception of Icelandic greylag geese, all of the goose populations predicted to be experiencing overharvest show strong population growth. This conflicting result raises concern about current population size estimates, harvest estimates or both.We found no relationship between sustainable harvest indices and short-term or long-term wintering trends in harvested species, or conservation classification under the UK’s Birds of Conservation Concern framework.Policy Implications: Our results suggest that UK based harvest is unlikely to be a major determinant of population trends for overwintering waterbirds in the UK. Additionally, the lack of a relationship between conservation classifications and SHI strongly suggests that these are not an appropriate tool for making decisions about harvest management. Our assessment provides the basis for a framework to make evidence-based decisions on sustainable harvest levels in the UK in the face of incomplete data. Investment in data collection for European waterbird population size and harvest is long overdue.