How much dentists are ethically concerned about overtreatment; a vignette-based survey in Switzerland

Abstract

BackgroundOvertreatment (or unnecessary treatment) is when medical or dental services are provided with a higher volume or cost than is appropriate. This study aimed to investigate how a group of dentists in Switzerland, a wealthy country known to have high standards of healthcare including dentistry, evaluated the meaning of unnecessary treatments from an ethical perspective and, assessed the expected frequency of different possible behaviors among their peers.MethodsA vignette describing a situation that is susceptible for overtreatment of a patient was presented to a group of dentists. The vignette was followed by five options. A questionnaire including the vignette was posted to 2482 dentists in the German-speaking areas of Switzerland. The respondents were asked to rate each option according to their estimation about its prevalence and their judgment about the degree to which the behavior is ethically sound.Results732 completed questionnaires were returned. According to the responses, the most ethical and the most unethical options are considered to be the most and the least prevalent behaviors among dentists practicing in Switzerland, respectively.ConclusionsSuggesting unnecessary treatments to patients seems to be an ethically unacceptable conduct in the eyes of a sample of dentists in Switzerland. Although the respondents believed their colleagues were very likely to behave in an ethical way in response to a situation that is susceptible to overtreatment, they still seemed to be concerned about the prevalence of unethical behaviors in this regard.

Carious lesion management in children and adolescents by Australian dentists

“…Several reasons have been proposed as to why dentists intervene surgically too early. These include remuneration, misunderstanding of evidence‐based treatment, assumption that more interventive care is better, patients’ expectation for a procedure to be performed and not advice given, misunderstanding of the consequences of under‐ and over‐treatment, and, lack of faith in the ability of non‐invasive treatments to halt caries progression …”

Complaints about dental practitioners: an analysis of 6 years of complaints about dentists, dental prosthetists, oral health therapists, dental therapists and dental hygienists in Australia

“…Given that 85% of dental practitioners work in the private sector, and that even insured patients may face high out of pocket costs, this result is not surprising. International commentary suggests that cost‐related concerns and over‐servicing are more common in fee‐for‐service systems, whereas under‐treatment tends to arise in capitated practices . Regardless of the cause, these findings raise important ethical issues for the dental profession insurers and government funders.…”

Does competition affect the clinical decision‐making of dentists? A geospatial analysis

“…The reason for dichotomizing the outcome, aside from the simplicity of data analysis and presentation, was to try and identify the factors associated with dentists' leanings in clinical decision‐making (relatively conservative vs relatively aggressive). The case scenario questions were developed from the literature and with the help of dental faculty members at the University of Toronto . The process also involved pilot testing the questions for face validity among twenty dental practitioners.…”

“…The case scenario questions were developed from the literature and with the help of dental faculty members at the University of Toronto. 27,28 The process also involved pilot testing the questions for face validity among twenty dental practitioners.…”