How Outsourcing Social Services to NGOs Bolsters Political Trust in China: Evidence from Shanghai

Abstract

The Chinese Communist Party has recently acknowledged its attempts to bolster good governance by outsourcing public and social service functions to social organizations—non-profit organizations, either created by relevant government bureaus, developed through non-profit incubators, or voluntarily created civil society groups. Do these services gender political trust for the party-state? Using matching methods on an original survey data collected in communities in Shanghai, this article reveals two important findings. (1) Service efficacy—the internal belief that one can affect the content of the services show strong correlation with political trust and the relationship is stronger than that between service quality and political support. (2) There is strong evidence for credit transfer—whilst accountability for these services is attributed to grassroots actors and there is strong correlation between service efficacy and political support, political support increases only for the central government level. The results show how the new programs of social service outsourcing and incorporation of non-governmental organizations in service provision can increase support for the party-state.

Explaining the expansion of the NGO sector in China: Through the lense of adaptive corporatist governance

“…One of these is the establishment of non‐profit incubators ( shehuizuzhifuhuajidi ) at the local level that facilitates the establishment of service‐oriented NGOs. Often, the members of the incubated organization are civilians or found with the help from the residents' committee by drawing active members of the community, and funded by the neighborhood committee (Song, 2022). The nonprofit incubators provide office space and professional training for fundraising strategies and project planning free of charge.…”

“…For example, in 2018, there were 26 incubators in Shanghai alone(Song, 2022).29 Document 9: A ChinaFile Translation. https://www.chinafile.com/document-9-chinafile-translation#start, retrieved March 15, 2024.…”

The Impact of Political Trust Among the Egyptian Youth on Adaptation to the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…Despite this, Chinese citizens perceived their democracy as being as high as that of the United States and Taiwan (Zhai, 2022). It was also identified as among the few countries in the world with a high level of trust (Edelman Trust Barometer, 2022), attracting considerable attention in prior research on political trust (e.g., Song et al, 2022;Wu & Wilkes, 2018;Zhao & Hu, 2017;Jiebing et al, 2016;Liang, 2016;Li, 2016;Cui et al, 2015;Chen et al, 2010). Similarly, on the countrylevel, Egyptians exhibited significantly greater trust in their state authorities than did citizens of other countries in the region (Albrecht & Loewe, 2022).…”

The Evolution of China’s Foreign Talent Policy: the Case Study of Beijing

“…China embarked on a reform aimed at realizing the ‘democratization’ and ‘scientificalization’ of decision-making 17 to reflect criticisms of the high concentration of decision-making power, plus the non-institutionalized decision-making process as regards China’s political system before 1978 (Zhou 2011 : 109; Shen 2013 ). The policy outcomes are thus inevitably influenced by both the formal institutional actors and informal institutional actors (e.g., Zuo 2022 ; Song 2022 ). With the reform, more actors have become involved in FTP’s decision-making.…”