How Policy Fields Are Born: The Rise of Democratic Security in Argentina

Abstract

This essay maps the transformation of security from a symbol of authoritarian government under the Cold War paradigm of National Security into a public good and a policy field acknowledged as legitimate and democratic by politicians and policy experts. Using present-day Argentina as an example, we show how security ideas gain dominance across the political spectrum, displacing and subordinating democratic politics conceived in terms of rights. As institutions increasingly accept security measures and pre-emptive risk management, a securitising discourse – despite its claims to advocate for the ‘citizen’ – trumps governance and the rule of law. Appealing to citizens’ concerns and rights, the new forms of securitisation may yet undermine democratic life.

What is punitive populism? A typology based in media communication

“…convergência crescente de políticas entre os principais partidos políticos adversários em favor de políticas duras contra o crime (Seri & Kubal, 2019). Em 2015, os três principais candidatos presidenciais concorreram com plataformas duras contra o crime.…”

It's (Almost) Always the Economy: Economic Performance and Political Realignments in Argentina in 2019

“…The Macri government's approach to security was significantly different from the policies under the Kirchners' administrations. The previous administrations' policies focused on social issues that underlie crime -such as poverty or inequality (Seri and Kubal 2019). This was perceived by large sectors of society as extremely weak and light-handed with crime.…”

What democratic policing is … and is not

“…Such violence reflects approaches to crime control and protest policing that are distinct from the above rhetoric and policies, and more similar to crime control under previous governments. Indeed, Seri and Kubal (2019) track a convergence of political leaders' discourses on the ideological left and right on human rights and security from 2003 to 2015. This convergence led to an eventual common frame of security as a human right that can be protected through increasing the presence of police officers.…”