How similar, how different? On Dutch media depictions of older and younger people

Abstract

By providing information on society at large, the media help to establish and maintain relations between various social groups, such as between younger and older people. They may also disturb the formation or maintenance of such relations,e.g.by stimulating the ‘othering’ of the out-group members. The aim of the present study was to trace how the different strategies of ‘othering’ are applied by Dutch news media in their portrayal of older and younger citizens. The analysis showed that the most notable discrepancies in the media coverage of the two age groups appear in (the nature of) their evaluation. While the negative descriptors of older characters relate more frequently to their (alleged) incompetence, the negative depictions of younger actors refer predominantly to their lack of benevolence. In the case of positive evaluations the reverse is true: older characters are more often presented as warm and younger people as competent. The results of the study are interpreted in the light of literature on social distance and (social) practices of ‘othering’.

Youth climate activists meet environmental governance: ageist depictions of the FFF movement and Greta Thunberg in German newspaper coverage

“…In newspaper coverage, young people are portrayed as an inherently different social group, who are to be kept out of public spaces. Although, in line with Lepianka (2015b), we expected that this portrayal is key to 'othering' youngsters, it is unexpected that this othering includes an image of illegitimate youth climate activism and a structural underestimation of young activists' abilities and capabilities of knowing and exerting their climate interests. Media propensity to criminalize youth remains obvious.…”

“…Westman's argument has been widely confirmed, in research on the marginalization and exclusion of young people from public spaces (Moris and Loopmans 2019) and the criminalization of youth (Lepianka 2015a(Lepianka , 2015bLevinsen and Wien 2011;Welch et al 2002). Gendron et al (2016) point at the complexity of ageist language, which includes unintended as well as well-intentioned ageist remarks, ranging from contempt, derogatory expressions to positive images of youth.…”

“…Ageist media representations of young people have received much less scholarly attention. Some scholars have detected negative media depictions of youth as lacking warmth (Lepianka 2015b) or focussing on crime especially for non-native youth (Lepianka 2015a;Welch, Price, and Yankey 2002). While others have found neutral representations and an increase in quoting youngsters (Levinsen and Wien 2011) or positive portrayals in terms of competence (Lepianka 2015b).…”

How architectural design affords experiences of freedom in residential care for older people

“…Indeed, we found amongst residents a limited sense of group belonging, and, even more, clear instances of 'othering', i.e. practices of setting a group of people apart as different (Lepianka, 2015(Lepianka, , pp. 1098(Lepianka, -1099Mountz, 2009).…”

Loneliness among older people in the Swedish media : Constructions, discourses and the designation of responsibility

“…These findings suggest, therefore, that ageing is not solely an inevitable natural and biological process. Studies indicate that there is a dualistic understanding of ageing and older people in society at present and that older people are often rated high on traits associated with warmth (generous, helpful or kind) and low on competence (forgetful, conservative, narrow-minded or dependent) (Lepianka, 2015). Furthermore, Hummert et al (2004) found that older and younger adults have stereotypes of both older and younger people.…”