How task constraints affect inspiration search strategies

Abstract

Searching for sources of inspiration is central to creative design; however, we have limited knowledge of individual inspiration search strategies in response to varying levels of task constraints. We studied 39 high-school students' inspiration search strategies using Google Images. Low task constrainedness led to divergent search marked by quick iterations, limited design task usage, and a heterogeneous image set. Intermediate constrainedness prompted in-depth, on-task exploration characterized by slow and careful iterations with more search result examination, extensive design task usage, and homogenous images. High constrainedness led to flexible bracketing with quick, flexible design task use, ending with heterogeneous images. Images from the intermediately and highly constrained conditions generated more ideas and were perceived as more inspiring (relative to low) in a new group of students. We discuss the idea of a 'sweet spot' of constrainedness in an inspiration search process in design and consider implications for design research and future work.

Exploring the Role of Creativity in Software Engineering

“…Working with constraints has been mentioned several times during all sessions. Highly constrained conditions generate more ideas and are generally perceived as more inspiring [23].…”

Kreativitetsfremmende hjemmetræning under Covid-19

“…Det er dog meget forskelligt, hvad den enkelte udøver opfatter som udfordrende, sjove og meningsfulde opgaver. Biskjaer et al (2020) argumenterer således for, at alle har et individuelt "sweet spot" for, hvilke begraensninger der skal til at vaere kreativ. Torrents et al (2020) betegner begraensninger som 'the motor creativity paradox', fordi begrebet (engelsk: 'constraints') typisk opfattes som restriktioner, der skubber deltagerne i en bestemt retning og derfor eliminerer andre handlemuligheder.…”

Rapid Response! Investigating the Effects of Problem Definition on the Characteristics of Additively Manufactured Solutions for COVID-19

“…In comparison, failure of safety-critical PPE (e.g., face masks) with complex functional and regulatory requirements could expose healthcare workers to grave dangers. Prior research suggests that the complexity [24][25][26][27] and urgency [28,29] of problems influence the creativity of the solutions developed for them, especially in DfAM settings [30,31]. As previously discussed, many of the challenges arising from the COVID-19 pandemic are urgent and have complex functional and regulatory requirements (e.g., face masks) compared with other challenges related to the pandemic that have less urgent and relatively simpler requirements (e.g., hands-free door openers).…”