How Valid Are Measures of Children’s Self-Concept/ Self-Esteem? Factors and Content Validity in Three Widely Used Scales

Abstract

Children's self-esteem/self-concept, a core psychological construct, has been measured in an overwhelming number of studies, and the widespread use of such measures should indicate they have well-established content validity, internal consistency and factor structures. This study, sampling a demographically representative cohort in late childhood/early adolescence in Dublin, Ireland (total n = 651), examined three major self-esteem/self-concept scales designed for late childhood/early adolescence: Piers-Harris Self-Concept Scale for Children 2 (Piers et al. 2002), Self-Description Questionnaire I (Marsh 1992) and Self-Perception Profile for Children (Harter 1985). It also examined findings in light of the salient self factors identified by participants in a linked mixed-methods study. The factor structure of Piers-Harris Self-Concept Scale was not replicated. The Self-Description Questionnaire I and Self-Perception Profile for Children were replicated only in part although in similar ways. In all three scales, a global/ appearance self evaluation factor accounted for the largest variance in factor analyses. Sport/athletic ability, school ability, school enjoyment, maths and reading ability/enjoyment, behaviour, peer popularity, and parent factors were also identified but did not always reflect existing scale structures. Notably, the factors extracted, or items present in these scales, often did not reflect young people's priorities, such as friendship over popularity, the importance of family and extended family members, and the significance of Child Ind Res (2019) 12:1507-1528 https://doi.incremental personal mastery in activities rather than assessing oneself as comparatively good at preferred activities. The findings raise questions about how self-esteem/self-concept scales are used and interpreted in research with children and young people.

Correlations of self-esteem with academic competencies and gender variations

“…In addition, a qualitative survey found that children value areas and content not found in these scales. Guerin and Tatlow-Golden (2018) attribute this to the fact that those scales are generally designed by adults, with little or no reference to children's representations.…”

The Influence of Smartphone Games on Students’ Self-Concept

“…Children's self-concept is an important core of their psychological structure and has been measured in a large number of studies. The wide application of these measurement tools shows that they have perfect content validity and internal consistency [26]. Selfconcept test tools have been established based on various theoretical backgrounds, theories, and measurement procedures, and because the content, meaning, and structure of the measurement tools varied, numerous tools have been developed [14].…”

The role of self-perceived academic competence in children with childhood-onset fluency disorder

“…To conduct the examination of self-esteem and self-perception in children, self-reported questionnaires are usually used. One of the most well-known, reliable, and valid self-report questionnaires is the “Self-Perception Profile for Children” (SPPC; Harter, 1985) scale (Guerin and Tatlow-Golden, 2019). The SPPC has been translated into and adapted for Greek (Makri-Botsari, 2001), and its validity has been tested in several Greek studies (e.g.…”