Human Development: Beyond the Human Development Index

Abstract

The well-known Human Development Index (HDI) encompasses only three rather basic aspects of human welfare. This paper aims to go beyond this, by identifying 11 categories of human development. We next propose plausible candidates as indicators of these categories. We then estimate correlations among the indicators within each category, discarding those that are highly correlated with others. This left 39 indicators to encompass the categories. Of these, eight indicators are highly correlated with the HDI and may therefore be represented by it. But 31 are not highly correlated, suggesting that a full assessment of human development requires a much broader set of indicators than the HDI alone. Following the same procedure, we find that under-five mortality rates perform equally as well as the HDI, and income per capita is less representative of other dimensions of human development. The HDI (and the other two broad indicators) are shown to be worse indicators of the extended categories of human development for OECD countries than for developing countries.Human development, Economic growth, Comparative country studies,

On Weighting the Components of the Human Development Index: A Statistical Justification

“…McGillivray (1991), Trabold-Nubler (1991), Streeten, P. (1995), Morse (2003)). It does not take into account other dimensions of well-being, such as security, political participation and human rights Sen (1992, 2000), Ranis et al (2006)), or the distribution of human development within a country (Sagar and Najam, 1998, Grimm et al 2008. 1 Another criticism of the HDI is that it uses an essentially arbitrary weighting scheme of the three component indices, namely a simple average (Kelly (1991), Noorbakhsh, 1998;Srinivasan (1994), Ravallion (1997), Grimm et al (2008)).…”

Economic Growth and Human Development in Developing Countries: Virtuous or Vicious Circle?

“…Jedná se o index složený ze tří dílčích indikátorů, které měří úroveň vzdělání, zdravotní péče a životního standardu. HDI je však jen nepřesným a hrubým vyjádřením lidského rozvoje podle Senova přístupu, kritizován je mimo jiné pro absenci politických či environmentálních indikátorů nebo indikátorů příjmové nerovnosti (viz například Ranis et al, 2005nebo Syrovátka, 2008.…”

Measuring of human development through the output-oriented super efficiency VRS DEA model without inputs

“…Ranis et al (2005) stressed the need of neglecting some relevant dimensions and identified new categories encompassing all the major dimensions of human development. Sanusi (2008) implied that housing facilities and housing conditions increased the scope of human development, and thereby tried to widen the scope of issues covered by the HDI.…”