Human Perception of Structure in Shaded Space-Filling Visualizations

Abstract

Very early in the object recognition process the human visual system extracts shading information. While shading can enhance the visibility of structures, it can have a negative impact on the judgment of sizes of elements in a structure. In certain visualization systems the underlying hierarchical structure is not noticeably explicit, such as in space-filling techniques. We hypothesize that in such cases, shading can make the structure more explicit. In this paper, we report the results of two experiments designed to investigate the effects of shading information on extracting the structure in space-filling visualizations. In the first experiment subjects performed better with the visualization tool with shading on structure-based tasks. Our results do not show that shading impairs users' judgment on size-based tasks. A subjective evaluation shows that users preferred interacting with the system when shading was available. The second experiment was designed to investigate further users' capacity to identify structural elements within the space-filling visualization. A substructure recognition task was employed in this experiment and results show that users are capable of identifying sub-structures quicker and with fewer errors when the visualization tool was equipped with shading information than without. The results of both experiments provide evidence that shading information can be used to effectively obtain structural information from spacefilling visualizations.

Judging Correlation from Scatterplots and Parallel Coordinate Plots

“…The standard approach in information visualization for the assessment of new techniques is to carry out a task with an existing and a new method, and to measure the time needed and the errors made. [24][25][26][27] Such a comparative evaluation was carried between parallel coordinates and stardinates (a glyph-based technique with multiple dimensions represented on asterisk-like axes). 24 The efficiency and effectiveness of the two visualization methods were compared based on the task completion time, the number of correct answers, the number of hypotheses and on how subjective statements were in agreement with expert views.…”

Examining Entrepreneurs' Presentation Effectiveness in Generating Stakeholder Interest: Observations From the Medical Device Industry

“…Hue and intensity are examples of color‐based preattentive processing. For example, shading is a preattentive attribute that influences human cognition and recognition (Irani, Slonowsky, and Shajahan‐Human ). In general, experimental studies have demonstrated that individuals recognize and process shaded information more quickly than adjacent, nonshaded entities, objects, or text.…”

Visualization of the Static Aspects of Software: A Survey

“…A Shadowed Cushions Treemap [104] is another visual technique designed to provide a better insight into the internal structure of the Treemap. Experiments in [105] have shown that users prefer interacting with this shadowed cushion Treemap and are faster in performing a substructure identification.…”