“…The United States has long had an uneasy relationship with international human rights (eg, Soohoo et al, 2009). From a reluctance to ratify treaties-the United States is famously the only UN member state not to accept the 1989 Convention on the Rights of the Child (Bartholet, 2010;Lee, 2010)-to a skepticism over the HRC, and a lack of willingness to accept human rights monitoring, the United States tended to appear keener on monitoring others than on being monitored itself.…”
Section: Amplification Of the Pushback Against Human Rightsmentioning
Human rights during power transitions. In K. Stiles, & J. Oestreich (Eds.), Global institutions in a time of power transition: governing turbulence (pp. 81 -101). (The ACUNS Series on the UN System). Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.
“…The United States has long had an uneasy relationship with international human rights (eg, Soohoo et al, 2009). From a reluctance to ratify treaties-the United States is famously the only UN member state not to accept the 1989 Convention on the Rights of the Child (Bartholet, 2010;Lee, 2010)-to a skepticism over the HRC, and a lack of willingness to accept human rights monitoring, the United States tended to appear keener on monitoring others than on being monitored itself.…”
Section: Amplification Of the Pushback Against Human Rightsmentioning
Human rights during power transitions. In K. Stiles, & J. Oestreich (Eds.), Global institutions in a time of power transition: governing turbulence (pp. 81 -101). (The ACUNS Series on the UN System). Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.
“…recognition of the right to health and health care access and a recognition that governments have an affirmative obligation to address and reform policies and programs that have a disparate impact on women and communities of color (2009). …”
Section: Reproductive Justice and Human Rightsmentioning
This article presents an overview of reproductive justice as a theoretical and activist paradigm developed in response to reproductive oppression in the United States, and focuses on the reproductive justice needs of Native American women, as well as the responses developed by Native American women and their allies to these needs. I make explicit the links between reproductive justice, environmental justice and human rights for Native American communities, and articulate the ways in which reproductive healthcare for Native American women as it is provided by the Indian Health Service (IHS) acts as a fulcrum for these links. Ultimately, the failure of the IHS to meet the reproductive healthcare needs of Native American women reflects the failure of the federal government to meet its obligations to Tribal nations; further, these failures produce structures of reproductive oppression in Native communities which scholars and activists seek to redress utilizing the rubric of women’s reproductive health.
“…Our argument is that the actor-based approaches used in human rights scholarship do not provide the tools to adequately capture the dynamics within local authorities. This carries the risk of overlooking the role of individual agency in 'bringing human rights home' to the city level (Soohoo, Albrisa, & Davis, 2008).…”
Section: The Missing Piece: Conceptualising the Individual Agency Of ...mentioning
This dissertation explores the interplay between the politics of human rights and forced migration in several Dutch and German municipalities. It sought to answer the question of why and how municipal actors engage with human rights in the context of forced migration, and through which encounters and spaces human rights-based approaches to the reception and inclusion of forced migrants develop. To guide my inquiry into this twofold question, five sub-questions on themes running through the chapters of this dissertation were formulated. These five questions focus on municipal actors’ (1) motives for engaging with human rights, (2) their understandings of human rights, (3) their frames and strategies to legitimate municipal approaches in this area, (4) the spaces and encounters through which human-rights based responses develop (5) and the spaces through which their limits manifest.
First of all, my PhD research shows that even in relatively hospitable environments, where international legal norms and principles are widely endorsed, municipal actors carefully weigh different strategies and navigate dilemmas when invoking human rights. They use human rights as a source of inspiration for local human-rights based approaches to the reception and inclusion of forced migrants and as a source of legitimation to justify local divergence from national policies.
Secondly, I highlight how municipal actors have different understandings of the local relevance of human rights and responsibilities regarding forced migration. By focusing on institutional, rather than everyday settings, I tried to bring into focus how local engagements with human rights may centre on contesting understandings of human rights responsibilities and duty bearers, as opposed to rights holders and norm addressees (forced migrants). In the last two chapters of this thesis, I zoom in on how different (normative) understandings of arrival shape local efforts to develop rights-based approaches to the reception and inclusion of forced migrants.
Third, this thesis points to different strategies to legitimate municipal involvement, and argues it is important to differentiate between discursive, discreet and discretionary strategies and to consider the implications of their application in different settings.
Fourth, the thesis offers a spatially aware examination of the politics of human rights and forced migration, by examining how institutional settings and public spaces in cities, towns and rural municipalities, are more than simply a stage for encounters between forced migrants and municipal actors, because the functions, design and artefacts of these spaces also mould the local politics of human rights and forced migration.
Fifth, this investigation brings into focus how municipal actors and other actors negotiate the limits of rights-based approaches to forced migration and zooms in on airports and asylum seeker centres as sites where the limits of municipal mandates and rights-based approaches are negotiated.
To conclude, this thesis argues that exploring these five dimensions is essential to understanding the complexities of local human-rights based responses to forced migration and to developing a broad understanding of the local interplay between the politics of human rights and forced migration in these different German and Dutch localities.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
