Human rights violations, detention conditions and the invisible nature of women in European immigration detention: a legal realist account

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper was to conduct a legal realist assessment of women’s situation in European immigration detention which focuses on relevant international and European human rights instruments applicable to conditions and health rights in detention settings, academic literature and relevant European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) jurisprudence since 2010. Design/methodology/approach In spite of the United Nations human rights frameworks and European Union (EU) standards, conditions in European immigration detention settings continue to pose a health risk to those detained. Migrant health rights when detained are intertwined with the right not to be subjected to arbitrary detention, detention in conditions compatible for respect for human dignity and right to medical assistance. Migrant women are particularly vulnerable requiring special consideration (pregnant and lactating women; single women travelling alone or with children; adolescent girls; early-married children, including with newborn infants) in immigration detention settings. Findings The situation of women in immigration detention is patchy in EU policy, academic literature and ECtHR jurisprudence. Where referred to, they are at best confined to their positionality as pregnant women or as mothers, with their unique gendered health needs ill-resourced. ECtHR jurisprudence is largely from male applicants. Where women are applicants, cases centre on dire conditions of detention, extreme vulnerability of children accompanying their mother and arbitrary or unlawful detention of these women (with child). Originality/value Concerns have been raised by the European Parliament around immigration detention of women including those travelling with their children. There is a continued failure to maintain minimum and equivalent standards of care for women in European immigration detention settings.

Violación de los Derechos Humanos de mujeres migrantes internacionales durante el trayecto migratorio: revisión sistematizada

“…Nadie podrá ser arbitrariamente detenido, preso ni desterrado. (Becerra et al, 2022;Esposito et al, 2016;Gómez et al, 2017;Kirby, 2020;van Hout, 2022) Criminalización Art. 9. ídem (Becerra et al, 2022;Gómez et al, 2017) Daños psicológicos Art.…”

‘Women’s right to health in detention’: United Nations Committee Observations since the adoption of the United Nations Rules for the Treatment of Women Prisoners and Non-custodial Measures for Women Offenders (Bangkok Rules)

“…Women's unique health needs in many regions of the world are often neglected by the male dominated and ill-resourced detention system. United Nations Human Rights Committee and Special Rapporteur reporting, and contemporary academic reviews indicate that women (including transgender women) continue to experience discrimination, poor standards of care and a lack of access to gender-appropriate healthcare when in prisons and immigration detention, including the denial of food, detention in compulsory drug treatment centres, use of physical and pharmacological restraints and denial of opioid substitution treatment (Alirezeai and Roudsari 2020; Lungu Byrne et al 2020;Pillay, Chimbga and Van Hout 2021;Van Hout 2021;Van Hout and Crowley 2021;Van Hout and Mhlanga-Gunda 2018;Van Hout and Wessels 2021;Van Hout, Hillis and Kewley 2020;Van Hout, Lungu Byrne and Germain 2020).…”

Dental Caries, Periodontal Health Status, and Oral Hygiene Related Habits of Women Behind Bars in Central Jail Karachi, Sindh, Pakistan

“…4 Prisoners are more vulnerable to a wide range of health problems including alcohol and drug abuse, infectious diseases, chronic diseases, psychosocial and psychiatric problems. 5 One area that is currently under-researched is the oral health status of individuals in the prison environment. Prisoners are a vulnerable and socially deprived group requiring attention as they are often neglected with little or no access to health…”