Humanoid Cognitive Robots That Learn by Imitating: Implications for Consciousness Studies

Abstract

While the concept of a conscious machine is intriguing, producing such a machine remains controversial and challenging. Here, we describe how our work on creating a humanoid cognitive robot that learns to perform tasks via imitation learning relates to this issue. Our discussion is divided into three parts. First, we summarize our previous framework for advancing the understanding of the nature of phenomenal consciousness. This framework is based on identifying computational correlates of consciousness. Second, we describe a cognitive robotic system that we recently developed that learns to perform tasks by imitating human-provided demonstrations. This humanoid robot uses cause-effect reasoning to infer a demonstrator's intentions in performing a task, rather than just imitating the observed actions verbatim. In particular, its cognitive components center on top-down control of a working memory that retains the explanatory interpretations that the robot constructs during learning. Finally, we describe our ongoing work that is focused on converting our robot's imitation learning cognitive system into purely neurocomputational form, including both its low-level cognitive neuromotor components, its use of working memory, and its causal reasoning mechanisms. Based on our initial results, we argue that the top-down cognitive control of working memory, and in particular its gating mechanisms, is an important potential computational correlate of consciousness in humanoid robots. We conclude that developing high-level neurocognitive control systems for cognitive robots and using them to search for computational correlates of consciousness provides an important approach to advancing our understanding of consciousness, and that it provides a credible and achievable route to ultimately developing a phenomenally conscious machine.

Could you hate a robot? And does it matter if you could?

“…7 To support this claim, Frank and Nyholm emphasise that many researchers are either actively working to create robotic consciousness (Prabhaker 2017), or are discussing the conditions that would need to be met for a robot to be conscious (Bryson 2012;Dennett 1994). Further evidence of current attempts to create conscious robots can be seen in the work of Reggia et al (2019). They argue that.…”

Is it pain if it does not hurt? On the unlikelihood of insect pain

“…Artificial intelligence-generated characters can respond to simulated damage with limps and wound guarding (e.g., Fallout 4; www.youtube.com/watch?v=Znn1EwpfOgA). Robots are also capable of observational learning (Reggia et al 2018). These abilities suggest that subjective experience is not required for complex, motivated behaviour.…”

Computational Modeling of Prefrontal Cortex for Meta-Cognition of a Humanoid Robot

“…Recent advancements in paradigms of artificial intelligence and cognitive neuroscience can contribute to the evolution of their technologies [1,2]. In the next decades, it is expected that humanoid robots having cognitive skills will be widely used in social areas such as assistive, entertainment, and rehabilitation fields [3][4][5][6]. Robots using social areas require some human-like cognitive skills such as reasoning, decision making, problem-solving [4].…”

“…Such projects are rapidly increased, and they are expected to rise as an emergent issue in the future. Some very good and remarkable examples related to a computational architecture based on cerebral/neocortex models of the brain were presented in recent years [1][2][3][4][5][6]. In these studies, various machine learning methods were employed for modeling of embodied cognition and adaptive behavior.…”