Numerous approaches and inputs for nonlinear finite element analysis used for modeling reinforced concrete systems under cyclic loads have been outlined. Practitioners usually take into account a number of significant factors when modeling, for example deciding upon the constitutive relations, the connection among concrete and steel reinforcement, and the mesh sensitivities, in order to accurately simulate the nonlinear response of reinforced concrete under cyclic loads. Therefore, it is essential to thoroughly assess popular modeling approaches and develop a reliable modeling approach with reliability, stability, and consistency. A modeling technique and practical guidelines for nonlinear finite element analysis of reinforced concrete frames subjected to cyclic loading are described in this study, taking into account the influence of parameters such as dilation angle, stiffness recovery, friction coefficient, and mesh sizes. The hysteretic force–displacement behavior and load-carrying capacity of reinforced concrete frames subjected to cyclic loading have been compared using numerical and experimental curves. Discrete fracture paths are specified in the model’s geometry to achieve an accurate depiction of the stress distribution and an adequate fit of the hysteretic behavior. The proposed modeling approach provides a precise representation of the stress distribution and hysteretic behavior while keeping computational costs reasonable.