To test the significance of ultrafast protein folding signals (< <1 msec), we studied cytochrome c (Cyt c) and two Cyt c fragments with major C-terminal segments deleted. The fragments remain unfolded under all conditions and so could be used to define the unfolded baselines for protein f luorescence and circular dichroism ( Many recent publications describe submillisecond foldingrelated signals (1) and interpret these signals in terms of the rapid formation of productive folding intermediates. Our earlier results lead us to question this interpretation. We found that the folding rate of cytochrome c (Cyt c) is limited by an initial, time-requiring, nucleated polypeptide chain collapse (2). The nucleated collapse represents the rate-limiting step for overall folding when folding is two-state and it limits the rate at which intermediates can populate when folding is more than two-state, i.e., when an even larger misfold-reorganization barrier is encountered in subsequent folding (3). The nucleated collapse itself appears to be limited by a large scale diffusion-dependent conformational search, culminating in the assembly of a transition state nucleus that can support forward folding steps in an energetically downhill manner. For Cyt c the initial search-nucleation step requires about 1 msec under the most favorable conditions, and results available for other small proteins when starting from the fully unfolded state seemed to us to be generally consistent with a similar requirement (2). However, this view of the strategy for the initiation of folding now appears to be contradicted by many recent reports of much faster folding events, both in Cyt c and other proteins.This paper considers the significance of ultrafast protein folding signals. The results show that when unfolded Cyt c is diluted from high denaturant in folding experiments, it experiences a fast polymer chain contraction from a more extended form of the unfolded state to a more contracted form of the unfolded state. The optical signals produced by the chain contraction can misleadingly mimic the formation of a distinct folding intermediate. Rather, the supposed intermediate is the unfolded state itself.An assessment of available fast folding observations in this light shows them to be consistent with the view that folding is limited by an obligatory, initial, time-requiring (Ϸ1 msec) search-nucleation step.
MATERIALS AND METHODSHorse heart Cyt c (highest available grade) was from Sigma Chemical Company. Cyt c fragments were produced by partially selective cyanogen bromide cleavage (4) at the methionine residues, Met-65 and -80, purified by reverse phase HPLC (C18 column, acetonitrile gradient), and verified by mass spectrometry. F1-65 was virtually pure. The F1-80 preparation was contaminated (Ϸ10%) with a species close to Cyt c in mass. Molar concentration of the fragments was measured by absorbance using an extinction coefficient at 401 nm of 137,000 M Ϫ1 ⅐cm Ϫ1 in denaturing guanidinium chloride (GdmCl), obtained by comparison with holo Cy...