Bleaching of young leaf tissue is a common response to the herbicide mesotrione and varies from one application to another. To better elucidate factors that may contribute to perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne L.) phytotoxicity from mesotrione, studies were conducted at Blacksburg, VA. Continuous field monitoring of temperature, humidity, solar radiation, soil moisture, and leaf wetness was used to elucidate environmental conditions that led to perennial ryegrass injury by mesotrione applied at 0.14 kg a.i. ha−1. The study found that 2 of 17 weekly treatments caused unacceptable perennial ryegrass injury at two field sites. Ten‐day temporal trends prior to mesotrione treatment showed that temperature, for one injury event, and volumetric soil water content, for the other injury event, were exclusively correlated to visually and digitally assessed perennial ryegrass injury. Both instances suggest that alleviation of suboptimal temperature or moisture with more optimal growing conditions influenced the turf injury response. Additional studies in growth chambers showed that carotenoid levels and turf phytotoxicity were strongly temperature dependent and followed a quadratic response with peak injury occurring at perennial ryegrass growth optima. Carotenoid levels decreased and perennial ryegrass injury increased in response to increased mesotrione rate. These data suggest that mesotrione is more likely to injure perennial ryegrass turf when used at higher rates and under conditions of rapid turfgrass growth.