An enantioselective dearomative 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of 2-nitrobenzothiophenes and isatin-derived azomethine ylides with a bifunctional hydrogen-bonding thiourea catalyst was established, giving polyheterocyclic compounds in excellent results (up to 99% yield, >20:1 dr for all cases and up to 99% ee). The enantioselectivity could be reversed by the bifunctional hydrogenbonding squaramide catalyst containing the same chiral source as in the thiourea catalyst. DFT calculations revealed the origin of the observed stereochemistry and the reversal of enantioselectivity.