It is possible to evolve RNA enzymes in a continuous manner by employing a simple serial-transfer procedure. This method was previously applied only to descendants of one unusually fastreacting RNA enzyme with RNA ligase activity. The present study establishes a second continuously evolving RNA enzyme, also with RNA ligase activity, but with a completely independent evolutionary origin. Critical to achieving the fast catalytic rate necessary for continuous evolution, development of this enzyme entailed the addition and evolutionary maturation of a 35-nucleotide accessory domain and the application of highly stringent selection pressure, with reaction times as short as 15 ms. Once established, continuous evolution was carried out for 80 successive transfers, maintaining the population against an overall dilution of 10 207 -fold. The resulting RNA enzymes exhibited Ϸ10 5 -fold improvement in catalytic efficiency, compared with the starting molecules, and became dependent on a structural feature of the substrate that previously conferred no selective advantage. This adaptation was eliminated by deleting the substrate feature and then carrying out 20 additional transfers of continuous evolution, which resulted in molecules with even greater catalytic activity. Now that two distinct species of continuously evolving enzymes have been established, it is possible to conduct molecular ecology experiments in which the two are made to compete for limited resources within a common environment.in vitro evolution ͉ RNA catalysis ͉ RNA ligase ͉ selection ͉ serial transfer D arwinian evolution has been applied to populations of RNA molecules in the laboratory to generate RNA enzymes (ribozymes) that catalyze a variety of reactions (1-3). These experiments involve repeated rounds of selective amplification and mutagenesis to drive the evolving population toward desired catalytic behaviors. Of the many ribozymes that have been obtained by in vitro evolution, six different classes catalyze the RNA-templated joining of an oligonucleotide 3Ј-hydroxyl and an oligonucleotide 5Ј-triphosphate, forming a 3Ј,5Ј-phosphodiester and releasing inorganic pyrophosphate (4-9). This reaction is similar to that carried out by protein polymerases that catalyze the synthesis of biological RNAs.All six of the known 3Ј,5Ј-ligase ribozymes achieve rate enhancements of several orders of magnitude, compared with the uncatalyzed rate of templated RNA ligation, which is Ϸ10 Ϫ7 min Ϫ1 (10). Notably, only derivatives of the class I ligase, first described by Bartel, Szostak, and colleagues (4, 11), have been able to achieve a catalytic rate of Ͼ1 min Ϫ1 . Because of the superior catalytic rate of this ribozyme, it has been chosen as the starting point for several subsequent in vitro evolution experiments. One series of studies led to the development of a sequence-general, RNA-dependent RNA polymerase ribozyme that can add as many as 20 NTPs (12, 13). This effort involved several structural modifications of the class I ligase, including the addition of a larg...