Ideal Particle Sizes for Inhaled Steroids Targeting Vocal Granulomas: Preliminary Study Using Computational Fluid Dynamics

Abstract

Objectives Vocal fold granulomas are benign lesions of the larynx commonly caused by gastroesophageal reflux, intubation, and phonotrauma. Current medical therapy includes inhaled corticosteroids to target inflammation that leads to granuloma formation. Particle sizes of commonly prescribed inhalers range over 1 to 4 µm. The study objective was to use computational fluid dynamics to investigate deposition patterns over a range of particle sizes of inhaled corticosteroids targeting the larynx and vocal fold granulomas. Study Design Retrospective, case-specific computational study. Setting Tertiary academic center. Subjects/Methods A 3-dimensional anatomically realistic computational model of a normal adult airway from mouth to trachea was constructed from 3 computed tomography scans. Virtual granulomas of varying sizes and positions along the vocal fold were incorporated into the base model. Assuming steady-state, inspiratory, turbulent airflow at 30 L/min, computational fluid dynamics was used to simulate respiratory transport and deposition of inhaled corticosteroid particles ranging over 1 to 20 µm. Results Laryngeal deposition in the base model peaked for particle sizes 8 to 10 µm (2.8%-3.5%). Ideal sizes ranged over 6 to 10, 7 to 13, and 7 to 14 µm for small, medium, and large granuloma sizes, respectively. Glottic deposition was maximal at 10.8% for 9-µm-sized particles for the large posterior granuloma, 3 times the normal model (3.5%). Conclusion As the virtual granuloma size increased and the location became more posterior, glottic deposition and ideal particle size generally increased. This preliminary study suggests that inhalers with larger particle sizes, such as fluticasone propionate dry-powder inhaler, may improve laryngeal drug deposition. Most commercially available inhalers have smaller particles than suggested here.

Impact of endoscopic craniofacial resection on simulated nasal airflow and heat transport

“…On the contrary, after the 2 sides of the airway converge beyond the septum, turbulent fluctuations arise in the nasopharynx region and these fluctuations dominate the flow in the posterior parts of the airway continuing into the pharynx. Thus, understandably, earlier CFD models for laryngeal airflow have implemented turbulence models . A similar convergence of airflow from the 2 sides of the frontal nose happens at a much more anterior region (at the resected end of the septum) in CFR subjects and the resultant mixing justified the use of turbulence modeling to obtain a realistic idea of the flow profile.…”

Topical anesthetic techniques in office‐based laryngeal surgery: A comparison of patient preferences

“…It is possible that direct cannula instillation into the larynx may trigger an initial cough and gag response that prevents adequate infraglottic anesthesia necessary for some procedures, whereas direct instillation by tracheal puncture more assuredly instilled the correct dose into the trachea that is then coughed up into the larynx for local anesthesia. Regarding the nebulizer, it has become clear that nebulizers variably deposit particles in the upper aerodigestive tract, with particle size being particularly important . The nebulizer is not necessarily targeted to the larynx.…”

Upper airway reconstruction using long‐range optical coherence tomography: Effects of airway curvature on airflow resistance

“…However, we should still note the caveat that a faster airflow or narrower airways might push the Re values, which presently lie in the transitional zone, beyond the threshold limit for sustained turbulence. To generate a realistic flow profile, the simulations would then require an exclusive implementation of turbulence modeling schemes .…”