The authors examined whether the baseline cognitive functioning of 21 clinically normal huntingtin mutation carriers who developed manifest Huntington's disease on follow-up differed from that of 49 mutation carriers who remain asymptomatic over the same period in a longitudinal study. One hundred thirty-four gene-negative offspring of Huntington's disease patients were studied as well. Overall, there were no differences in cognitive test performance among the three groups. However, "converters" who developed signs of Huntington's disease within 8.6 years demonstrated poorer performance on the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test at baseline. People with the Huntington's disease mutation who are carefully examined neurologically and found to be asymptomatic have, at most, very minimal problem-solving impairment, and only if they are within a few years of clinical onset.Since the discovery of the genetic mutation responsible for Huntington's disease, 1 there have been many attempts to determine whether people who carry the mutation, but who are not yet clinically ill, can be distinguished from those without the mutation. Brain imaging studies have often demonstrated structural and/or functional abnormalities in the striatum in presymptomatic individuals. [2][3][4][5][6][7] In addition, subtle oculomotor and other movement peculiarities and neuropsychiatric changes have been reported in some mutation-positive individuals prior to the onset of clinical signs and symptoms sufficient for diagnosis. [8][9][10][11][12] However, the search for presymptomatic changes in cognition among those with the huntingtin mutation has met with mixed results. Several investigations reported no significant differences in neuropsychological functioning between those with and those without the Huntington's disease mutation. [13][14][15][16][17] Others, however, have found such differences. [8][9][10]18 Deficits in reaction time, psychomotor and processing speed, 10,18,[20][21][22] executive functioning, 23-25 spatial analysis and constructional praxis, 26 verbal fluency, 23 verbal memory, [26][27][28] and mental arithmetic 9,10 have all been reported among mutation carriers, albeit inconsistently.The discrepant findings among studies are due, in large part, to methodological differences. First, studies have varied in the degree of neurologic abnormality tolerated in the "asymptomatic" mutation-positive group. 29 While some researchers enrolled only persons with no, or very minimal, nonspecific neurological signs, 22,27 others included subjects with "major signs consistent with Huntington's disease." 8,9,20,28 In addition, some studies were of young mutation carriers who were almost certainly many years from disease onset, whereas others were of older subjects nearing the age of likely clinical onset. In those studies where
NIH-PA Author ManuscriptNIH-PA Author Manuscript NIH-PA Author Manuscript proximity to clinical onset was explicitly addressed, time to disease onset ("conversion") was most often estimated. 10,[15][16][17]28 The pre...