Forty years have passed since the dramatic identification of mRNA, the unstable carrier of genetic information from DNA to protein (15,48,56). During the last decade, there have been scores of papers and reviews that assume that RNase E is the central enzyme for degradation of mRNA. (There have been hundreds of papers and many reviews on RNase E and mRNA degradation, with at least 60 just in the last 2 years. I regret the unintentional omission of worthy ones but only refer to examples in this short presentation.) It is appropriate to consider evidence for and against this conclusion since it bears on our understanding of overall pathways of metabolism. RNase E was identified in 1978 by Apirion et al. (4,44,96) as an endoribonuclease (endo-RNase) that catalyzed the maturation of 5S rRNA by two sequential cleavages at specific sites of the 9S RNA of Escherichia coli. About the same time, Kuwano (recently from training with Apirion) et al. isolated an unusual temperature-sensitive mutant called the ams (for altered mRNA stability) mutant (73,107). About a decade later, it was shown that the ams mutation maps in the gene for RNase E, rne (9,95,99,130). This identification contributed to the now widely held view that RNase E is the principal RNase for initiation of mRNA decay (e.g., see references 33, 34, 35, 49, 57, 87, 122, and 124).
FUNCTIONAL DECAY AND MASS DECAY SHOULD BE CONSIDERED SEPARATELYIt is important to recognize the useful compartmentalization of the degradation of an mRNA population for a specific protein (message) into two distinct components: inactivation or loss of function (the ability to synthesize protein) as opposed to loss of mass. It is also important to recognize that decay rates are measured on populations of millions of molecules and are used to infer how a single molecule is degraded. Loss of mass of a heterogeneous population of mRNAs is defined empirically by loss of trichloroacetic acid-precipitable material; the lost fraction generally includes oligonucleotides of less than 12 to 15 nucleotides (nt). For mRNA for a specific protein (message), it has been defined by loss of oligonucleotides that cannot form stable hybrids with their cDNA. The minimal size depends on the stringency of the hybrid reaction and the base composition but is often in the 15-to 30-nt range. A 500-nt mRNA population would only show loss of mass if cleavages occurred near the ends or if it were degraded by an exonuclease. Other terms have been used, such as "bulk decay" and, most commonly, "chemical decay." Mass decay is more specific, since "chemical" could refer to any number of parameters from chemical modifications to structural alterations, as well as loss of mass.Functional decay (inactivation) is defined here by loss of the "capacity" of an mRNA molecule to participate in the initiation of synthesis that leads to the normal functional protein product. It is the rate-limiting event for determining the amount of functional protein from the message, as well as for the onset of rapid degradation of the inact...