Identity work by a young petite female academic home comer: quest for social power in masculine settings

Abstract

PurposeHow do females with multiple sources of identity deal with intersectional identity tensions and perceived lack of access to social power? The study focuses on how social relationships form and develop in masculinised settings between construction workers and a petite female researcher through perceived notions of equality and inequality. Through autoethnographic tales, the study examines how an academic home comer navigates between conflicting professional and cultural identities, in their native country.Design/methodology/approachUsing collaborative autoethnography, the study examines how the intersections of being a young petite female and a “partial” insider in a male-dominated construction industry influences the researcher's identity work process and her quest for social power.FindingsThe findings suggest that to access referent social power, the researcher covers stigmatised intersectional attributes and reveals a more favourable identity. The fieldwork journey of the young petite female researcher highlights that identity work is a situational process that evolves with respondent relationships, respondent assigned roles, perceived notion of access to power and struggles of cultural versus professional identity. The reader is also taken through the collaborative autoethnographic journey of a female researcher and her doctoral studies supervisor.Originality/valueThis paper makes several contributions. First, it contributes to the academic literature on intersectionality of identity, especially concentrating on the intersectional attributes of petite physical stature, gender and perceived lack of access to social power. Second, this paper theorises identity work processes as an indirect strategy of social power in researcher-and-researched relationships. Last, through collaborative autoethnography of female researchers' fieldwork journey, this study contributes to the body of knowledge on academic home comers as “partial” insiders in their native country.

The Emotional Machiavellian: Interactions Between Leaders and Employees

“…In male-dominated industries, individuals believe emotions can induce decision-making bias (Lerner et al, 2004 ). For engineers, maintaining professionalism is essential to sustain a masculine character (Liyanagamage & Fernando, 2022 ). As a result, they might suppress and deny emotions (Naoum et al, 2020 ).…”

“…Consequently, their employees perceive project managers as ‘managers’ but not as ‘leaders’ (Russell & Stouffer, 2003 ). Furthermore, relationships within construction sites are influenced by highly masculine ideologies (Liyanagamage & Fernando, 2022 ). It is one of the most male-dominated trades (George & Loosemore, 2019 ).…”

Sisterhood in academia: building a flock culture to cope and thrive

“…Fernando et al, 2020) have provided qualitative richness and conceptual insights into marginalized academic voices. Following the work of Liyanagamage and Fernando (2022), we used collaborative autoethnography (CAE) to contribute to the extant literature to understand our teaching experiences as female academics better. Thus, the present study does not aim to explore the broad issue of female under-representation in the higher education sector, nor do we claim to investigate this problem comprehensively.…”