“…Recently, a taskspecific subseries aimed at performing imaging, i.e., locating reflectors in space, has been identified and tested on analytic data for simple 1D-earth examples with encouraging results ͑Weglein et al Shaw, 2001;Shaw et al, 2001;Weglein et al, 2001;Shaw et al, 2002a, b;Innanen and Weglein, 2003;Shaw et al, 2003a, b;Weglein et al, 2003;Shaw et al, 2004;Shaw, 2005;Liu et al 2005a, b͒ have shown the first multidimensional acoustic examples of the methods for determining the correct spatial location of reflectors without knowing or determining the overburden velocity model. As the analysis of Weglein et al ͑2000͒ andShaw et al ͑2004͒, with respect to the possibility and requirements for a model-type independent imaging algorithm, and the diagrams of describing inverse scattering interactions within the imaging subseries, show, a model-type independent algorithm would require both reflection and transmission data.…”