“…A final line of research has reflected the assumption that the success of language learners depends on possibilities for involvement in a variety of foreign language ''communities of practice'' (Peirce, 1995;Toohey & Day, 1999). Yet many European and Asian countries have successfully produced learners with the functional ability in foreign languages to carry on a conversation or to read and write high school-level texts, even with little or no possibility for the learners to have such involvement (Bjö rklund, 1997;Duff, 1997;Eng, Gan, & Sharpe, 1997;Johnson, 1997). Given that researchers hold these widely divergent views on the need for involvement in communities of practice, we suggest that motivation, beliefs, and attitudes that govern the success or failure of foreign language acquisition depend on contextual factors (Kouritzin, 2004), such as a nation's sociocultural contexts (Nieto, 1999;Pennycook, 1994) and its historical legacy (Canagarajah, 1999;Phillipson, 1992).…”