Immigrants’ Chances of Being Hired at Times of Skill Shortages: Results from a Factorial Survey Experiment Among German Employers

Abstract

Within the context of increasing international labour migration, this article analyses immigrants' chances of being hired in a foreign country by identifying key criteria in employers' recruitment decisions. We focus on the German labour market because the prospering economy and demographic change led to an increase in the number of vacant positions, particularly in medium-skilled occupations. The German government, therefore, facilitated labour market access for foreign skilled workers with the intention of minimising shortages on the labour market by means of evaluating the foreign education investments of individuals. However, employers' perception of the labour market integration of foreign skilled workers has barely been examined. In order to directly consider human resources professionals, we use a factorial survey experiment to simulate different hiring scenarios for applicants from Germany and both European and non-European countries. Our design can distinguish between the effects of external circumstances, such as applicant shortages, and applicant-specific characteristics, including nationality, foreign certificates or language skills. The findings reveal that immigrants experience greater chances of being hired in the German labour market in understaffed occupations and in businesses which expect future skill shortages. Language skills and country-specific work experience also substantially improve immigrants' chances of being hired. However, foreign qualifications are viewed more critically during recruitment processes.

The Impact of Forced Answering and Reactance on Answering Behavior in Online Surveys

“…This practice is problematic, especially when survey topics tap into personally sensitive domains, for example, such as sexual behavior (e.g., Dombert et al, 2016), relationship abuse (e.g., Taylor & Mumford, 2016), substance use (e.g., Soussan & Kjellgren, 2016), suicidal behavior (e.g., Stickley & Koyanagi, 2016), delinquent and criminal behavior (e.g., Grant et al, 2016), attitudes and prejudice toward immigrants (e.g., Ceobanu & Escandell, 2010), discrimination on the labor market (e.g., Mergener & Maier, 2019), political extremism (e.g., Pauwels & Hardyns, 2018), questionable research practice (e.g., Fiedler & Schwarz, 2016), or workplace bullying perpetration (e.g., Sischka et al, 2019) to name just a few. Sensitive questions cover “not only questions that trigger social desirability concerns but also those that are seen as intrusive by the respondents or that raise concerns about the possible repercussions of disclosing the information” (Tourangeau & Yan, 2007, p. 859).…”

Economic literacy among beginning higher education economics students in Japan and Germany and its socio-demographic influencing factors

“…In Germany, more than half of all bachelor’s graduates go on to enroll in a master’s degree (Herrmann, 2008). In addition, German companies focus particularly on professional qualifications and often directly involved in the further development of their employees, for example, in dual study programs (Müller et al, 1998; Mergener and Maier, 2019).…”

Review of the Construction Labour Demand and Shortages in the EU

“…To that end, the German government is supporting the integration of foreign skilled workers and has introduced reforms. For persons who have completed vocational education and training in specially defined shortage occupations, the German Employment Regulation provides access to their labour market [55]. While in Austria, the inflow of labour migrants from third countries has been regulated by quotas until July 2011, it has been substituted for a point system of economic immigration of third-country citizens.…”