“…At low pH, namely using acid KCl aqueous solution as the electrolyte, the proposed H + reduction reaction at cathode (Cu 3 VSe 4 NSs-FTO thin film) is , which consumes hydrogen ions; whereas, at high pH (pH = 10), the reaction at cathode consumes water rather than H + , being 48 , 49 . The consumption of water takes place via an extra water dissociation , thus, the process of photocatalytic reduction is naturally slowed at higher pHs 50 , in turn, the larger amount of H + present at acid pH facilitates the H 2 production. Besides, at pH of 4, the surface of Cu 3 VSe 4 NSs-FTO thin film is positively charged by adsorbing H + , facilitating the reduction reaction, whereas, at higher pH (pH of 7 and 10) the electrode/electrolyte interface is neutral or negatively charged, which eliminates the electrostatic interaction, or even creates a strong electrostatic repulsion towards Cl − that results in a lower hole capture rate and in a low production of hydrogen 51 .…”