Impact of mono or polyculture systems on water quality, growth performance and economic efficiency of Oreochromis niloticus (Linnaeus, 1758) and Hypophthalmichthys molitrix (Valenciennes, 1844)

Abstract

The aim of this study was to investigate the effect of the graded replacement of stocking density rate (0, 4, 8 and 12%) of the monosex Oreochromis niloticus by the silver carp, Hypophthalmichthys molitrix as a mono (T 1 ) or poly-culture systems (T 2 , T 3 , and T 4 , respectively) for 124 days (4 months) on water quality parameters, growth performance and feed efficiency parameters, condition factor, fish organs indices, fish body composition. The total production of O. niloticus and economic efficiency parameters were evaluated in each treatment. An experimental field study was conducted in covered floating net cages in the Lake Manzala. The obtained results revealed the positive effects of rearing O. niloticus in poly-culture systems with H. molitrix compared to mono-culture system of O. niloticus (T 1 ). O. niloticus reared in poly-culture system at stocking rate 4% (T 2 ) or 8% (T 3 ) with H. molitrix significantly (P ≤ 0.05) improved the growth rate, feed efficiency (feed intake, feed conversion ratio, protein and energy utilization), and chemical composition of the fish body (crude protein, ether extract, energy content) parameters of both fish species. While, O. niloticus reared in poly-culture system with 12% silver carp (T 4 ) gave the highest total output, total profit, and economic efficiency (%) among all the experimental mono (T 1 ) or poly-culture systems with silver carp (T 2 and T 3 ). Thus, it could be concluded that monosex O. niloticus reared with H. molitrix at 4% (T 2 ), and 8% (T 3 ) in poly-culture systems are the best aquaculture systems among the experimental mono (T 1 ) or other poly-culture system with 12% H. molitrix (T 4 ). But economically, O. niloticus reared in poly-culture system with 12% silver carp (T 4 ) is the best aquaculture system among all the experimental systems.

Assessment of production, physiological responses, and economic efficiency of the Nile tilapia, Oreochromis niloticus (Linnaeus, 1758) reared at different stocking densities in a polyculture system

“…2) in the present study. Furthermore, improvements in the body composition of fish reared in polyculture compared to fish reared in monoculture conditions are previously reported (Khalil et al, 2008;Mehrim et al, 2016). In the same line with the current findings, Mehrim et al (2018) reported that the body composition of O. niloticus reared in polyculture systems significantly improved compared to those reared in monoculture system.…”

“…Many studies indicate that polyculture system gives the highest growth performance and survival rate of reared fish species compared to those in monoculture system (El-Sagheer et al, 2008; Mehrim et al, 2016Mehrim et al, , 2018 et al, 2001). Several studies showed the importance of determining the appropriate stocking density, especially in polyculture system, which is reflected in their productivity and profitability (Uddin et al, 2007;Abdel-Hakim et al, 2014;Shoko et al, 2016).…”