Impact of online learning on sense of belonging among first year clinical health students during COVID-19: student and academic perspectives

Abstract

Background The need to belong is a fundamental human desire that provides the basis for relationships and community; it provides a sense of security that enables growth and development. This sense of belonging is pivotal to new University students, indeed, without it, students are at greater risk of failing or withdrawing from their studies. Yet developing a sense of belonging within a new cohort is complex and multi-faceted and further complicated by a sudden shift away from in-person to online learning. Using the situated-learning framework, our study explores first year clinical health students’ sense of belonging in the context of the rapid transition to online learning because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Methods We utilised a current mixed-method approach including a survey incorporating previously validated tools, demographic and open-ended qualitative questions. Data was also gathered from three focus groups: two dedicated student groups and one academic focus group. Qualitative data was subjected to thematic analysis whilst descriptive statistics were used to describe the quantitative data. Results 179 first year students complete the survey and four students, and five academics were involved in the focus groups. All participants were from clinical health science courses at an Australian university. Our qualitative results indicated a global theme of: Navigating belonging during the COVID-19 crisis: a shared responsibility; with four organising themes describing (1) dimensions of belonging, (2) individual experiences and challenges, (3) reconceptualising teaching and learning, and (4) relationships are central to belonging. Conclusion While the rapid transition to online learning did not greatly impact knowledge acquisition of first-year students in this cohort, the lack of sense of belonging highlights the need for further research into development of this essential aspect of learning in the online domain. Although contextualised in the COVID-19 pandemic, it became clear that the findings will remain relevant beyond the current situation, as a student’s need to belong will always be present in the face of challenges or change.

Digital Dilemmas: A Comprehensive Review of the Psychosocial and Sleep Effects of Web Streaming on the Indian Youth

“…The convenience of accessing a diverse range of content at any moment may entice students into indulging in binge-watching sessions, leading to procrastination and compromising the quality of their study sessions. This shift in study behaviour highlights the importance of understanding how web streaming habits impact academic commitments, emphasizing the need for a nuanced approach to address the potential challenges that arise [ 11 - 12 ]. Recognizing this impact becomes crucial for ensuring that students maintain a healthy balance between academic responsibilities and digital entertainment.…”

Digitaliseringens begränsande gränslöshet – om lärande, rum och hemmahörande i högre utbildning

“…Somliga låter klassrummet variera beroende på tid och omständigheter (Amir et al,. 2020;Arnou et al, 2020;Barrot et al, 2021;Pokhrel & Chhetri, 2021;Tang et al, 2023). Forskningen visar dessutom att bland det mest bekymmersamma för studenterna var bristen på social interaktion och känslan av att vara ensam i sina studier, bostadens olämplighet som hemmakontor inklusive otillräcklig dataöverföringskapacitet samt bristande motivation och ork (Almendingen et al, 2021;Wackenhut & Gillette, 2022).…”

Belonging in Online Synchronous Classrooms: Experiences of Minoritized Students in Dutch Higher Education during the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…For many educators, sense of belonging is a valued concept in campus-based learning, being firmly linked with improved student attainment, increased learner satisfaction and reduced attrition rates [12]. They believe that the need to belong is a fundamental human desire that provides the basis for relationships and community and that this sense of belonging is pivotal to university students [13]. Amidst all the scholarly debates around what this new online and hybrid education meant in terms of "sense of belonging", a new line of discussion emerged about the prospect of online education for "inclusive education".…”