“…Within HfO 2 thin films, the nonequilibrium ferroelectric polar orthorhombic phase is most often reported to coexist with the equilibrium nonpolar monoclinic ( P 2 1 /c ) and nonequilibrium tetragonal ( P 4 2 / nmc ) phases. − Recent reports, meanwhile, have demonstrated a phase transformation from the antipolar orthorhombic phase ( Pbca ) to the polar orthorhombic ( Pca 2 1 ) phase with electric field cycling, suggesting that this often overlooked antipolar orthorhombic phase may play a significant role as a phase impurity, which impacts ferroelectric performance and influences the wake-up behavior observed in HfO 2 -based thin films. The interplay of these four phasesmonoclinic ( P 2 1 / c ), tetragonal ( P 4 2 / nmc ), antipolar ( Pbca ), and polar ( Pca 2 1 ) orthorhombicis necessarily complex and affected by several factors, including dopant/substituent type and concentration, − stress, − oxygen vacancies, , and film thickness or grain size. , Disentangling the interplay of these competing effects is difficult and necessary, and it requires accurate phase identification in thin films that are typically less than 30 nm thick …”