The self-reported experience of itch for autistic people has not been studied. Anecdote, theory, and emerging research suggest that itch experience is different in autistic people, with negative consequences. To address this, an online survey was completed by participants who self-categorised as diagnosed autistic (n=158), suspected autistic (n=37) or not autistic (n=85). We asked about three categories of itch: spontaneous, provoked, and itch caused by a medical condition, with questions focussed on severity, timing and duration, and impact on daily activities such as sleep. Across all categories of itch there was a pattern of greater severity, duration, and impact in diagnosed autistic people compared to non-autistic people, with large effect-size differences for spontaneous and provoked categories. Those with suspected autism largely fell between groups. Regression models showed itch severity associated with self-reported autistic traits. As expected, we found more dermatitis-related itch sufferers in autistic respondents. However, medical itch did not drive differences in spontaneous and provoked itch. Findings therefore suggest that the self-reported itch experience of autistic people is quantifiably more severe, longer lasting and of greater daily relevance, and that these differences cannot be attributed to the higher prevalence of skin dermatitis found in autism. Future studies are required to understand how itch experience fits into the broader picture of sensory differences, to understand mechanisms, and to develop management strategies for what can be a highly morbid experience.