Impact of the electron to ion mass ratio on unstable systems in particle-in-cell simulations

Abstract

The evolution of the Buneman and two-stream instabilities driven by a cold dilute mildly relativistic electron beam is studied as a function of the ion-to-electron mass ratio. The growth rates of both instabilities are comparable for the selected parameters if the realistic ion-to-electron mass ratio is used and the Buneman instability outgrows the two-stream instability for an artificially reduced mass ratio. Particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations show that both instabilities grow independently during their linear growth phase. The much lower saturation amplitude of the Buneman instability implies that it saturates first even if the linear growth rates of both instabilities are equal. The electron phase space holes it drives coalesce. Their spatial size increases in time and they start interacting with the two-stream mode, which results in the growth of electrostatic waves over a broad range of wave numbers. A reduced ion-to-electron mass ratio results in increased ion heating and in an increased energy loss of the relativistic electron beam compared to that in a simulation with the correct mass ratio.PACS numbers:

Quark-Novae in the outskirts of galaxies: An explanation of the Fast Radio Burst phenomenon

“…These numbers are comparable to those derived from PIC simulations (e.g. Dieckmann et al 2012;Moreno et al 2018);…”

“…At saturation, the electron energy gain is ∼ 10% of the beam electron kinetic energy; the protons energy gain is much less than that of chunk electrons (e.g. Dieckmann et al (2012); Moreno et al (2018)).…”

Quantitative identification of deposited energy in UV-transmitted KDP crystals from perspectives of electronic defects, atomic structure and sub-bandgap disturbance

“…Among them, m e { m i . 42,43 v ei represents the electron-ion collision frequency in the process of inverse bremsstrahlung: 41,44…”

Coupling multi-fluid dynamics equipped with Landau closures to the particle-in-cell method

“…2012; Moreno et al. 2018), including instabilities with excitation conditions that depend on the mass ratio (Shalaby et al. 2021, 2022).…”

“…Therefore, one frequently used trick to increase the computational efficiency in PIC simulations is to adopt a reduced ion-to-electron mass ratio to bridge the gap between the smallest time scale in the simulation and the larger time scale on which interesting physical processes occur. However, this might lead to artificial suppression of physical effects Hong et al 2012;Moreno et al 2018), including instabilities with excitation conditions that depend on the mass ratio (Shalaby et al 2021(Shalaby et al , 2022. This shows the need for a more efficient numerical method to complement the accurate results achieved by PIC simulations in order to enable simulations of realistic physics occurring on longer time scales.…”