Impact of the Farm Income Stabilization Insurance Program on Production Decisions in the Quebec Pork Industry: An Empirical and Theoretical Analysis

Abstract

The Farm Income Stabilization Insurance Program (ASRA) is an agricultural program implemented in several agricultural sectors in Quebec, including the pork sector. This article aims to empirically assess the effects of this program on production decisions in the pork industry in Quebec using a Vector Error Correction Model (VEC). As variables we used the pig supply, the price of pork, and stabilized income. The dataset contains information about the pork sector which cover the period 1981-2014. The annual average growth rate of the quantity offered in this period is 5.24%. The results suggest that the supply of pork is strongly correlated with lagged values of stabilized income. The results also show that there is only one long-term relationship between the three variables above-mentioned. By contrast, in the short term, an increase of one percentage point of the stabilized income leads to an increase of 0.80 percentage point of pork supply in the next period while an increase of one percentage point of pork price will result to a decrease of 0.47 percentage point of the production. Pork production decisions are dominated in short-term by the presence of ASRA program. This shows evidence that without the ASRA program, pork production would be less. These results confirm some of the criticisms of this program. Thus, through this article we suggest a compensation indicator which internalizes market signals in order to improve pork industry efficiency. Simulations of the compensation indicator were also performed. The adoption of this indicator as a measure of compensation for the ASRA program will generate an efficient production system, reduce the deficit of the program, and improve the competitiveness of pork industry. This indicator can be applied to other agricultural sectors covered by the ASRA program.

The impact of output price support on smallholder farmers' income: evidence from maize farmers in Ghana

“…In Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, incomes of smallholder farmers are low and characterized by sharp fluctuations ( Fanzo, 2017 ). This income instability is due to several factors that influence the supply of agricultural produce, such as weather changes and biological crises like disease outbreaks and pest invasions ( Atozou and Lawin, 2016 ). With agricultural production taking considerable time to complete, the cyclical shortage in supply leads to uncertainty in returns ( Gilbert and Morgan, 2010 ).…”

Socio-economic determinants of net-income in fish farming in Kainji Lake Basin, Nigeria onomic determinants of net-income in fish farming in Kainji Lake Basin, Nigeria

“…Finally, the variable "commodity price" was statistically significant (<0.01) and positively related to net-income of fish farmers. The price of a commodity has been shown to affect the income of farmers either positively or negatively (Demeke & Balie, 2016) depending on the demand, quantity supplied and several other factors such as weather changes and biological crisis (Atozou & Lawin, 2016). This means that under favourable conditions, an increase in the price of a commodity will positively result to an increase in income.…”

Short and Long-term Asymmetric Farm-Retail Price Transmission Analysis in the Canadian Agri-food Industry: Evidence from Dairy and Pork Sectors with Threshold Cointegration Models

“…In Quebec, the pork sector is covered by the Agricultural Income Stabilization Insurance Program. Atozou and Lawin (2016) showed that this program leads to a disconnection between production decisions and market conditions, thus generating overproduction regardless of the market price.…”