“…For the newer record, we can confirm that central Pacific events tend to start later in the calendar year than eastern-Pacific events (Kao and Yu, 2009), but found that most events of either type end up becoming basin-wide nevertheless, rendering their distinction less meaningful once fully established. In a related matter, we understand that so-called El Niño Modoki events (Weng et al, 2007(Weng et al, , 2009) are simplified versions of the 2nd principal component of the tropical Pacific SST field which by definition is orthogonal to the 1st principal component of this field (which, in turn, depicts the SST pattern associated with ENSO). However, since the Modoki SST pattern is frozen in space through the year (Weng et al, 2007), while the MEI (and MEI.ext) shows some seasonal variation of its loading patterns, it turns out that the MEI is not always orthogonal to Modoki SST.…”