Purpose
Laparoscopic surgery has demonstrated various advantages for the patients’ care, but also presents some difficulties for the surgeons, such as kinematic restrictions. Robotic comanipulation, in which control of instruments is shared between the robot and the surgeon, can provide adaptative damping assistance which allows stabilisation of movements. The objective of the present study was to determine the contribution of this assistance on a bimanual laparoscopic task.
Methods
Adaptative damping was studied on Peg Transfer task, performed by eighteen surgery-naive subjects. This exercise was repeated seven times without (Classic repetitions) and seven times with comanipulated robots (Robot repetitions), in a randomised order. We measured task performance, using Peg Transfer score; gesture performance, using hand oscillations and travelled distance; eye-tracking movements as an indicator of emergence of expertise. Participants’ perceived workload was assessed by NASA TLX questionnaire, and difference in impression between the two conditions by UEQ questionnaire.
Results
Adaptative damping improved gesture performance (oscillations
F
(1,17) = 23.473,
p
< 0.001,
η
2
= 0.580), with a statistically significant simple effect on the tool oscillation for both non-dominant (
p
< 0.001) and dominant hands (
p
= 0.005), without influencing task performance (mean Peg Transfer score
t
(17) = 0.920,
p
= 0.382,
d
= 0.29), but deteriorating eye-tracking movements associated with emergence of expertise (mean fixation rate per second F(1,17) = 6.318,
p
= 0.022, η
2
= 0.271), at the cost of a high perceived workload (NASA TLX score 59.78/100).
Conclusion
Assistance by adaptative damping applied by comanipulated robots improved gesture performance during a laparoscopic bimanual task, without impacting task’s performance without allowing the emergence of comportments associated with an expertise, and at the cost of a high perceived workload. Further research should investigate this assistance on more precise and clinical tasks performed by professionals.