A long standing controversy is whether an alternating activesite mechanism occurs during catalysis in thiamine diphosphate (ThDP)-dependent enzymes. We address this question by investigating the ThDP-dependent decarboxylase/dehydrogenase (E1b) component of the mitochondrial branched-chain ␣-keto acid dehydrogenase complex (BCKDC). Our crystal structure reveals that conformations of the two active sites in the human E1b heterotetramer harboring the reaction intermediate are identical. Acidic residues in the core of the E1b heterotetramer, which align with the proton-wire residues proposed to participate in active-site communication in the related pyruvate dehydrogenase from Bacillus stearothermophilus, are mutated. Enzyme kinetic data show that, except in a few cases because of protein misfolding, these alterations are largely without effect on overall activity of BCKDC, ruling out the requirement of a proton-relay mechanism in E1b. BCKDC overall activity is nullified at 50% phosphorylation of E1b, but it is restored to nearly half of the pre-phosphorylation level after dissociation and reconstitution of BCKDC with the same phosphorylated E1b. The results suggest that the abolition of overall activity likely results from the specific geometry of the halfphosphorylated E1b in the BCKDC assembly and not due to a disruption of the alternating active-site mechanism. Finally, we show that a mutant E1b containing only one functional active site exhibits half of the wild-type BCKDC activity, which directly argues against the obligatory communication between active sites. The above results provide evidence that the two active sites in the E1b heterotetramer operate independently during the ThDP-dependent decarboxylation reaction.Thiamine diphosphate (ThDP), 2 a derivative of thiamine or vitamin B 1 , is an essential cofactor for ThDP-dependent enzymes that mediate the decarboxylation of ␣-keto acids or the transfer of the glycoaldehyde moiety from a ketose to an aldose (1-3). ThDP-dependent enzymes in the form of homodimers (␣ 2 ), homotetramers (␣ 4 ), or heterotetramers (␣ 2  2 ) contain ThDP-binding pockets that constitute the two or four active sites of these enzymes. A long standing controversy in the literature has been whether these multiple active sites in a ThDP-dependent enzyme communicate with each other to affect the enzymatic reaction. An alternating activesite mechanism, or half-of-the-sites reactivity, was proposed, based on the negative cooperativity of ThDP binding to apotransketolase (4 -7). However, the crystal structure of the ␣-carbanion of (␣,-dihydroxyethyl)thiamine diphosphate in the active sites of yeast transketolase shows that the intermediate is present in high occupancy in both active sites, which does not support the alternating active-site mechanism in this enzyme (8). Yeast pyruvate decarboxylase, an ␣ 4 -type ThDPdependent enzyme, was shown kinetically to have two distinct pairs of active sites that alternate during the decarboxylation reaction (9). This kinetic model is supported by th...