Implant Patient Compliance Varies by Periodontal Treatment History

Abstract

Patients with implants partially comply with scheduled SPT, regardless of periodontitis history. Patients who had received periodontal treatment demonstrated better compliance than those without prior periodontal therapy experiences.

Compliance with supportive periodontal/peri‐implant therapy: A systematic review

“…Of these, 39 articles were eligible to be included in the systematic review. In addition, 4 articles were added from the references (Fardal, 2006;Kim, Lee, Chang, & Um, 2014;Konig, Plagmann, Langenfeld, & Kocher, 2001;Wilson et al, 1984); hence, a total number of 31 cohort studies (Agrawal, Jain, Jain, Agarwal, & Dubey, 2015;Cardaropoli & Gaveglio, 2012;de Carvalho et al, 2010;Checchi, Pelliccioni, Gatto, & Kelescian, 1994;Delatola, Adonogianaki, & Ioannidou, 2014;Demetriou, Tsami-Pandi, & Parashis, 1995;Demirel & Efeodlu, 1995;Famili & Short, 2010;Fardal, Johannessen, & Linden, 2003;Frisch, Ziebolz, Vach, & Ratka-Kruger, 2014;Galgut, 1991;Hu, Lin, Ho, & Chou, 2017;Kakudate, Morita, & Kawanami, 2008;Kim et al, 2014;Konig et al, 2001;Mendoza, Newcomb, & Nixon, 1991;Mendoza et al, 1991;Miyamoto, Kumagai, Jones, Dyke, & Nunn, 2006;Nicholls, 2006;Novaes & Novaes, 2001;Novaes et al, 1999;Novaes, Novaes, Moraes, Campos, & Grisi, 1996;Ojima, Hanioka, & Shizukuishi, 2001;Ojima et al, 2005 Wilson et al, 1984;Wilson, Hale, & Temple, 1993;Zeza et al, 2017), 4 cross-sectional studies (Fenol & Mathew, 2010;Gokulanathan, Balan, Aravind, & Thangavelu, 2014;Monje, Wang, & Nart, ...…”

“…The most common case definition of non-compliers concerned those who failed to show up after APT completion (Demetriou et al, 1995;Demirel & Efeodlu, 1995;Famili & Short, 2010;Galgut, 1991;Kim et al, 2014;Novaes et al, 1996;Perrell-Jones & Ireland, 2016;Si et al, 2016;Soolari & Rokn, 2003;Wilson et al, 1984Wilson et al, , 1993, whereas the most common definition for compliant patients regarded those who attended 100% after APT (Agrawal et al, 2015;Cardaropoli & Gaveglio, 2012;de Carvalho et al, 2010;Checchi et al, 1994;Costa et al, 2011;Demirel & Efeodlu, 1995;Fardal et al, 2003;Gokulanathan et al, 2014;Kakudate et al, 2008;Lee, Shin, Kim, & Pang, 2019;Mendoza et al, 1991;Miyamoto et al, 2006;Novaes & Novaes, 2001;Si et al, 2016;Soolari & Rokn, 2003;Wilson et al, 1984Wilson et al, , 1993Zeza et al, 2017). Erratic or irregular compliance case definition usually referred to patients who started SPT but discontinued or tended to show up irregularly.…”

“…non-compliers), the mean range between 1.69% and 64.4% (median: 29%; Q1: 20%; Q3: 39.3%) (Table 1) (de Carvalho et al, 2010;Delatola et al, 2014;Demetriou et al, 1995;Demirel & Efeodlu, 1995;Famili & Short, 2010;Frisch et al, 2014;Galgut, 1991;Kim et al, 2014;Monje et al, 2017;Novaes et al, 1996;Ojima et al, 2001;Perrell-Jones & Ireland, 2016;Ramseier et al, 2014;Si et al, 2016;Soolari & Rokn, 2003;Wilson et al, 1984Wilson et al, , 1993. Overall, 19 studies reported the number of fully compliers (compliance definition: 100% of the appointments) with mean range of 3.3% to 86.8% (median: 32%; Q1: 18.3%; Q3: 45.8%) in studies whose follow-up ranges between 1 and 10 years ( Frisch et al, 2014;Gokulanathan et al, 2014;Hu et al, 2017;Kakudate et al, 2008;Mendoza et al, 1991;Novaes & Novaes, 2001;Novaes et al, 1999;Perrell-Jones & Ireland, 2016;Si et al, 2016;Soolari & Rokn, 2003;Wilson et al, 1984Wilson et al, , 1993Zeza et al, 2017). Short-term (Agrawal et al, 2015, C de Carvalho et al, 2010, Checchi et al, 1994, Demirel & Efeodlu, 1995, Frisch et al, 2014, Hu et al, 2017, Mendoza et al, 1991…”

“…Overall, 19 studies reported the number of fully compliers (compliance definition: 100% of the appointments) with mean range of 3.3% to 86.8% (median: 32%; Q1: 18.3%; Q3: 45.8%) in studies whose follow-up ranges between 1 and 10 years ( Frisch et al, 2014;Gokulanathan et al, 2014;Hu et al, 2017;Kakudate et al, 2008;Mendoza et al, 1991;Novaes & Novaes, 2001;Novaes et al, 1999;Perrell-Jones & Ireland, 2016;Si et al, 2016;Soolari & Rokn, 2003;Wilson et al, 1984Wilson et al, , 1993Zeza et al, 2017). Short-term (Agrawal et al, 2015, C de Carvalho et al, 2010, Checchi et al, 1994, Demirel & Efeodlu, 1995, Frisch et al, 2014, Hu et al, 2017, Mendoza et al, 1991, Novaes et al, 1999, Novaes & Novaes, 2001, Si et al, 2016, Soolari & Rokn, 2003, Wilson et al, 1984, Wilson et al, 1993, Zeza et al, 2017, medium-term (Cardaropoli & Gaveglio, 2012;Fardal et al, 2003;Novaes et al, 1999;Perrell-Jones & Ireland, 2016;Zeza et al, 2017) and long-term studies (Novaes et al, 1999) exhibited mean range of fully compliers ranging between 3.3% and 77.1% (median: 31.6%; Q1: 21.9%; Q3: 50%), 13.7% and 86.8% (median: 33.6%; Q1: 26.8%; Q3: 45.8%); 11.1% and 37.3% (median: 18.4%; Q1: 13.8%; Q3: 25.8%), respectively.…”

Radiographic bone level around particular laser-treated dental implants: 1 to 6 years multicenter retrospective study

“…The method used for bone measurements was described in detail in Zeza et al [31]. Briefly, mesial and distal marginal bone level was recorded for each implant.…”