Implementation and Early Impacts of an Integrated Care Pilot Program in China: Case Study of County-level Integrated Health Organizations in Zhejiang Province

Abstract

Background: One of the most noticeable integrated care-related policies in China is the growth and proliferation of County-level Integrated Health Organizations (CIHOs), which take over a set of primary healthcare institutions to form an integrated delivery network in order to achieve an ordered hierarchical delivery system by strengthening primary care.Objectives: This paper presents emerging findings from an ongoing evaluation of the early impacts of the demonstrator site, Deqing CIHO, in Zhejiang Province, in order to examine the extent to which the implementation has achieved its core objectives: (1) establishing the hierarchical referral system, (2) capacity building of primary healthcare providers, and (3) reducing the costs.Design: This case study was conducted to determine institutional and managerial processes.Settings: Data were collected and analyzed at the CIHO and county level. A structured questionnaire was used for data collection.Primary and secondary outcome measures: Indicators were selected from the existing database of the county health system and arranged into three segments to assess (1) service utilization among each level of care; (2) capacity-building progress for primary care centers, (3) cost-related indicators for both levels of care.Results: Service utilization data show that one year after CIHO implementation, the proportion of patients who chose to get inpatient care outside of the county decreased from 27.3% to 24.5%. Hospital admissions were retrieved from outside the county, while service volume slightly shifted from hospitals to primary care sites. Capacitybuilding indicators for township health centers show that 6 out of 12 items showed better performance compared to the national average growth rate, and a moderated growth rate appeared in terms of per capita cost. Conclusion:Progress evaluation results from Deqing CIHO indicated some positive effects on three main outcomes, which reveal the potential of CIHOs in not only strengthening primary care but also controlling cost as a result of early implementation. Further emphases of evaluation are required to determine the impacts on the quality and experience of care that are estimated using claim-based data at the individual level.

Patients’ and Care Professionals’ Evaluation of the Effect of a Hospital Group on Integrated Care in Chinese Urban Health Systems: A Propensity Score Matching and Difference-in-differences Regression Approach

“…This demonstrated that strategies taken in the hospital group did not bring coordinated care to patients. 32 Several studies implied potential reasons for small or no differences in patients’ perception of integrated care. 33 - 35 Firstly, the inter-institutional coordination of health resources in the hospital group were not implemented well.…”

Do Primary Healthcare Facilities in More Remote Areas Provide More Medical Services? Spatial Evidence from Rural Western China

“…In order to mitigate the biases that may afect outpatient and inpatient visits of THCs other than remoteness of location, we controlled for a range of features of THCs, such as number of physicians, number of served populations, percentage of served populations aged 65 and above, government subsidies as a percentage of revenue [4], and type of THCs. Moreover, considering the possible crowding-out efect of local county hospitals on THCs [23][24][25], we included the number of available bed days in local county hospitals and county categories in regression models. For better presentation, we summarized the details about the values and attributes of the abovementioned variables in Table 1.…”