Implementing artificial intelligence in Canadian primary care: Barriers and strategies identified through a national deliberative dialogue

Abstract

Background With large volumes of longitudinal data in electronic medical records from diverse patients, primary care is primed for disruption by artificial intelligence (AI) technology. With AI applications in primary care still at an early stage in Canada and most countries, there is a unique opportunity to engage key stakeholders in exploring how AI would be used and what implementation would look like. Objective To identify the barriers that patients, providers, and health leaders perceive in relation to implementing AI in primary care and strategies to overcome them. Design 12 virtual deliberative dialogues. Dialogue data were thematically analyzed using a combination of rapid ethnographic assessment and interpretive description techniques. Setting Virtual sessions. Participants Participants from eight provinces in Canada, including 22 primary care service users, 21 interprofessional providers, and 5 health system leaders Results The barriers that emerged from the deliberative dialogue sessions were grouped into four themes: (1) system and data readiness, (2) the potential for bias and inequity, (3) the regulation of AI and big data, and (4) the importance of people as technology enablers. Strategies to overcome the barriers in each of these themes were highlighted, where participatory co-design and iterative implementation were voiced most strongly by participants. Limitations Only five health system leaders were included in the study and no self-identifying Indigenous people. This is a limitation as both groups may have provided unique perspectives to the study objective. Conclusions These findings provide insight into the barriers and facilitators associated with implementing AI in primary care settings from different perspectives. This will be vital as decisions regarding the future of AI in this space is shaped.

Exploring the Potential of Artificial Intelligence in Primary Care: Insights From Stakeholders’ Perspectives

“…While in a study by Darcel et al the regulation of AI was discussed as a factor affecting stakeholders trust in AI, along with implementation requirements, possible bias or inequity and acceptance by stakeholders [23]. The study found that implementation requirements could be a major problem area as each individual business may have differing infrastructure or data requirements.…”

“…Stakeholders within PC have access only to data that is required for their specific job role. Consequently, the complex organisational structure of the NHS and its multiple levels act as significant barriers to integrating technology into the healthcare system [20,23]. The following section explores the factors highlighted in the literature as barriers to AI acceptance.…”

Data-Driven Decision Support Tool Co-Development with a Primary Health Care Practice Based Learning Network

“…[1][2][3][4][5] Primary health care settings have received less attention than other sectors, and there is a need for increased engagement of end-users in development of AI-enabled decision support tools. 6,7 This case study describes the process and lessons learned thus far in co-developing a decision support tool with and for a primary health care organization in Ontario, Canada.…”