Implementing Integrated Care – Lessons from the Odense Integrated Care Trial

Abstract

Introduction:Creating coordination and concerted action between sectors of modern healthcare is an inherent challenge, and decision makers in search for solutions tend replicate new models across countries and settings. An example of this is the translation of the North West London integrated care pilot into a large-scale trial that took place in the Danish Municipality of Odense from 2013–2016. This article highlights the findings from our evaluation of the ill-fated project and discusses lessons learned.Methods:We examined implementation and short-term outcome in a multi-method evaluation based on qualitative interviews, direct observation, electronic surveys and quantitative analysis of change in service use and costs, using patient level data and a matched control group.Results and discussion:Despite an ambitious setup, ample financing, a shared governance structure and a well-functioning project organisation, implementation failed at the clinical level. Also, service use and costs for included patients increased significantly, without yielding the intended results. Primary explanations relate to an overly optimistic timeframe and a failure to take professionals’ wishes, daily practices and values into account. The results underline the importance of basing future attempts at integrated care on thorough studies of the perception of actual needs and timing, including rigorous pilot testing on a smaller scale, before attempting large-scale implementation.

Developing Normative Integration among Professionals in an Intersectoral Collaboration: A Multi-Method Investigation of an Integrated Intervention for People on Sick Leave Due to Common Mental Disorders

“…Research indicates that these integration activities can be hindered by a lack of effective communication, clear service goals, trust, commitment, and integrated leadership [514]. Differences in values among professionals have been identified as a key barrier to integration in vocational rehabilitation for people with mental disorders [1516]. Integration through the alignment of goals, values, culture, and norms has been termed normative Integration [17].…”

Evidence of Inter-Professional and Multi-Professional Interventions for Geriatric Patients: A Systematic Review

“…Some interventions involved physiotherapists, dietitians, occupational therapists and social workers [15,[20][21][22][23]. In fact, collaborative interventions by several different professions have been shown to be effective in improving patient-related outcomes [31][32][33]. As could be shown in a recent publication by LaDonna et al 2017 physicians, nurses as well as pharmacists should be part of the health care team [33].…”

Challenges and opportunities in pragmatic implementation of a holistic hospital care model in Singapore: A mixed-method case study

“….? SM01 To this, some suggested implementation of family medicine (FM) hospitalist model, where family physicians trained in General Medicine could also practise in an inpatient setting and eventually take on the role of principal doctor upon a patient's hospitalisation, given their wider knowledge on available community resources and ability to continue care beyond discharge [25,26]. Some also suggested working towards identifying and transferring care to named family physicians in the community as the long term care coordinators for patients with multimorbidity.…”