Importance of Partially Unfolded Conformations for Mg²⁺-Induced Folding of RNA Tertiary Structure:  Structural Models and Free Energies of Mg²⁺ Interactions

Abstract

RNA molecules in monovalent salt solutions generally adopt a set of partially folded conformations containing only secondary structure, the intermediate or I state. Addition of Mg2+ strongly stabilizes the native tertiary structure (N state) relative to the I state. In this paper, a combination of experimental and computational approaches is used to estimate the free energy of the interaction of Mg2+ with partially folded I state RNAs and to consider the possibility that Mg2+ favors "compaction" of the I state to a set of conformations with a higher average charge density. A sequence variant with a drastically destabilized tertiary structure was used as a mimic of I state RNA; as measured by small-angle X-ray scattering, it adopted a progressively more compact conformation over a wide Mg2+ concentration range. Average free energies of the interaction of Mg2+ with the I state mimic were obtained by a fluorescence titration method. To interpret these experimental data further, we generated molecular models of the I state and used them in calculations with the nonlinear Poisson-Boltzmann equation to estimate the change in Mg2+-RNA interaction free energy as the average I state dimensions decrease from expanded to compact. The same models were also used to reproduce quantitatively the experimental difference in excess Mg2+ between N and I states. On the basis of these experiments and calculations, I state compaction appears to enhance Mg2+-I state interaction free energies by 10-20%, but this enhancement is at most 5% of the overall Mg2+-associated stabilization free energy for this rRNA fragment.

Do conformational biases of simple helical junctions influence RNA folding stability and specificity?

“…While previous theoretical analyses of RNA stability have greatly enhanced our understanding of electrostatic contributions to RNA folding thermodynamics (Misra and Draper 2000;Misra and Draper 2002;Misra et al 2003;Draper 2004;Grilley et al 2007), they have also typically been unable to address the contributions arising from the junction . In these seminal studies, neglect of the contributions of the junction to the energetics of folding made the analysis tractable, but precluded a deep understanding of folding thermodynamics.…”

Unwinding RNA's secrets: advances in the biology, physics, and modeling of complex RNAs

“…However, the opposite conclusion has been drawn from fitting RNA folding transitions to PB predictions [70][71][72][73][74]. Ion-counting and SAXS experiments have provided a simple test for these effects and have revealed effects of ion size and valence that are not accounted for by PB theory, with deviations up to an order of magnitude in the systems investigated [58,75].…”

Bidentate RNA–magnesium clamps: On the origin of the special role of magnesium in RNA folding

“…For association of RNA with diffuse ions, the continuum approaches of Draper have been successful (Misra and Draper 2001;Grilley et al 2007;Draper 2008). Westhof and co-workers used molecular dynamics simulations to investigate binding of magnesium ions to phosphate oxyanions of a bacterial 5S rRNA and characterized Mg complexes containing a mixed binding mode (with both inner and outer shell coordination) (Auffinger et al 2003).…”