In order to illustrate the importance of a coupling effect in the physical-chemical structure of char-based catalysts on in-situ biomass tar reforming, three typical char-based catalysts (graphite, Zhundong coal char, and sawdust biochar) were studied in the fixed-bed/fluidized-bed reactor. The physical-chemical properties of carbon-based catalysts associated with their catalytic abilities were characterized by inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectroscopy (ICP-AES), Raman, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), scanning electron microscope–energy dispersive spectrometer (SEM-EDS) and N2 adsorption. The relationship between the specific reactivity and tar reforming ability of carbon-based catalysts was discussed through a micro fluidized bed reaction analyzer (MFBRA–MR). The results indicate that the char-based catalyst has a certain removal ability for in-situ biomass tar of corn straw in an inert atmosphere, which is as follows: sawdust biochar > Zhundong (ZD) coal char > graphite. During the in-situ tar reforming, the alkali and alkaline earth metal species (AAEMs) act as adsorption/reaction sites, affecting the evolution of the aromatic ring structure and oxygen-containing functional groups of the char-based catalyst, and also its pore structure. AAEM species on the surface of char-based catalysts are the active sites for tar reforming, which promotes the increase of active intermediates (C-O bond and C-O-AAEMs), and enhances the interactions between char-based catalysts and biomass tar. The abundant AAEMs may lead to the conversion of O=C–O and C=O to C–O. For tar reforming, the internal pore structure of char-based catalysts is little changed, mainly with the carbon deposit forming on the surface pore structure. The carbon deposit from the reformation of straw tar on the char surface has better reactivity than the inherent carbon structure of ZD coal char and sawdust biochar. There is a positive relationship between the MFBRA–MR specific reactivity and tar catalytic reforming ability of char-based catalysts (decided by the coupling effect in their physical-chemical structure), which can be used to determine the catalytic ability of char-based catalysts on tar reforming directly.