“…The other studies implementing ant colony optimization are ant colony optimization for permutation flowshop scheduling [3], ant colony optimization for job shop scheduling [4], applying ant colony optimization to increase the speed of the road network [5], ant colony optimization for solving the shortest path problem [6], ant colony optimization for generalized TSP problem [7], ant colony optimization for solving 3D TSP [8], and implementation of traveling salesman problem using ant colony optimization [9]. Meanwhile, the studies which improving ant colony optimization are solving traveling salesman problem based on ants with memory [10], modified ant colony optimization for grid scheduling [11], an improved ant colony optimization for machines scheduling [12], modified ant colony optimization by applying a local search procedure [13], Development of ant colony optimization based on statistical analysis and hypothesis testing [14], ant colony optimization with fault tolerance [15], a novel hybrid ant colony optimization [16], improved ant colony optimization forweapon-target assignment [17], ant colony clustering algorithm [18], improving ant colony optimization algorithm in transmission status rule [19].…”