Improvement in Anxiety and Pain After Whole Body Whirlpool Hydrotherapy Among Patients With Myofascial Pain Syndrome

Abstract

ObjectiveTo evaluate the effect of the Whirlpool hydrotherapy on pain and anxiety in chronic myofascial pain syndrome (MPS) patients, compared to the conventional hydrocollator pack therapy.MethodsForty-one subjects who have MPS in the upper trapezius muscles without depression were recruited. The patients were randomly assigned into two groups: the whirlpool therapy group whose bodies were immersed in a whirlpool bath at 34℃-36℃ for 30 minutes; the hydrocollator group who took a 30-minute application of a standard hot hydrocollator pack. Patients in both groups received therapy three days a week for 2 weeks and underwent several evaluations at baseline and after treatment. The variables we analyzed during evaluations were as follows: the primary outcome we considered was pain severity using a visual analogue scale. And the secondary outcomes examined included anxiety using the Korean version of the Beck Anxiety Inventory and quality of life (QoL) using the Korean version of the World Health Organization QoL Assessment, Brief Form. All follow-up values were compared with the baseline values.ResultsThe baseline parameters did not show significant differences between two groups. And after 2-week treatment, both groups revealed significant improvement in anxiety levels and QoL, as well as in pain. However, the improvement on pain (p=0.002) and anxiety (p=0.010) was significantly greater in the whirlpool group, compared to the hydrocollator group.ConclusionThe whirlpool hydrotherapy can be used as a more effective therapeutic method to reduce pain and anxiety in chronic MPS patients without depression.

Effects of Adjuvant Hydrotherapy on Functional Status and Mental Relaxation in Patients with Knee Osteoarthritis: Preliminary Study

“…And counter to our expectations, the study patients with mild to moderate OA did not express a depressive mood, anxiety, or low QoL at baseline. This result was contrary to our previous study in chronic myofascial pain syndrome 36) . That might be due to the pain severity.…”

The effectiveness of whirlpool for patients with neuropathic pain due to knee osteoarthritis

“…In a study with 41 subjects who have myofascial pain syndrome, the patients were randomly assigned into two groups: the whirlpool therapy group whose bodies were immersed in a whirlpool bath at 34°C-36°C for 30 minutes; the hydrocollator group who took a 30-minute application of a standard hot hydrocollator pack [32]. At the end of the study the improvement on pain and anxiety was significantly greater in the whirlpool group, compared to the hydrocollator group [32]. This result was explained by the gate theory; Due to the pressure and thermal temperature of hydrotherapy on the skin pain is relieved [33].…”

Effectiveness of hydrotherapy and balneotherapy for anxiety and depression symptoms: a meta-analysis

“…A review of the literature on the effectiveness of balneotherapy reported that balneotherapy improved depression and anxiety (Clark-Kennedy et al, 2021). In the study by Im and Han, whirlpool hydrotherapy was found to reduce anxiety significantly more than hot compresses (Im & Han, 2013). In a systematic review of the effectiveness of hydrotherapy during labor, it was found that hydrotherapy reduced maternal anxiety (Shaw-Battista, 2017).…”