Improving Healthcare Workers' Adherence to Surgical Safety Checklist: The Impact of a Short Training

Abstract

BackgroundAlthough surgery is essential in healthcare, a significant number of patients suffer unfair harm while undergoing surgery. Many of these originate from failures in non-technical aspects, especially communication among operators. A surgical safety checklist is a simple tool that helps to reduce surgical adverse events, but even if it is fast to fill out, its compilation is often neglected by the healthcare workers because of unprepared cultural background. The present study aims to value the efficacy of a free intervention, such as a short training about risk management and safety checklist, to improve checklist adherence.MethodsIn March 2019, the medical and nursing staff of the General Surgical Unit attended a two-lesson theoretical training concerning surgical safety and risk management tools such as the surgical safety checklist. The authors compared the completeness of the surgical checklists after and before the training, considering the same period (2 months) for both groups.ResultThe surgical safety checklists were present in 198 cases (70.97%) before the intervention and 231 cases (96.25%) after that. After the training, the compilation adherence increased for every different type of healthcare worker of the unit (surgeons, nurses, anesthetists, and scrab nurses). Furthermore, a longer hospitalization was associated with a higher surgical checklist adherence by the operators.ConclusionsThe results showed that a free and simple intervention, such as a two-lesson training, significantly stimulated the correct use of the surgical safety checklist. Moreover, the checklist adherence increased even for the operators who did not attend the training, maybe because of the positive influence of the colleagues' positive behaviors. As the results were promising with only two theoretical lessons, much more can be done to build a new safety culture in healthcare.

Healthcare Workers' Perceptions and Medically Approved COVID-19 Infection Risk: Understanding the Mental Health Dimension of the Pandemic. A German Hospital Case Study

“…However, there are some important lessons emerging from our case study in relation to health workforce governance and new approaches to organizational protection measures. For instance, ad-hoc action at the organizational level, like the development and implementation of short HCW training programmes, may help to respond effectively to new emergent needs ( 70 ).…”

Impact of surgical checklists on the time of surgical processes: a cross-sectional study

“…The opposite occurred in 2016, when there was a shorter time from beginning of anesthesia to beginning of surgery, and longer anesthetic-surgical time among patients with completion (partial or total) of the checklists. Researchers from Italy identified an association between length of hospital stay and adherence to the checklist, mainly justified by the clinical conditions of patients that result in greater clinical risk and, successively, in the occurrence of adverse events and prolonged hospitalization time28 .We highlight the low completeness of the checklist applied in the operating room in 2013, and little improvement in partial or total completion for the year 2016, including for the instrument applied in the inpatient units. This result reiterates that the implementation of surgical safety checklists takes time and requires persistence and strategic planning22 .Adherence to the application of the checklist and its completeness are related to the value attributed by the team and to the institution's management processes.…”

Strengths and weaknesses of the incident reporting system: An Italian experience

“…According to Ferorelli et al to educate operators with some theoretical lessons can improve healthcare workers' adherence to risk management tools. 2 In the psychiatric department most of the reported events occurred, most of which were aggressions. In the similar hospitals' IRS described by Tricarico and Ramirez, general medical services and surgery theatres are the bigger contributors to IRS.…”

“…1 Around one in twenty patients are exposed to preventable harm, causing additional hospital stays and negligence claims. 2 Risk management in healthcare needs a systemic and systematic approach and requires a suitable informative system. 3,4 In this context, the incident reporting system (IRS) has been recognized as essential for improving patient safety.…”